← sources

A question I would like to ask game devs from their perspective: why are so many modern AAA games seemingly designed around the premise that the player is a complete moron?

source: reddit (reddit:gamedev)published 2026-11-09 08:29ingested 2026-11-10 02:38

retained text

This is a post I made a while ago on the main gaming sub, but it was never really answered in a proper fashion and instead just descended into arguments over whether the point was even valid and whether I had some sort of agenda/defending the games in question. So hopefully it can be a bit calmer here.

For those unaware, the new Insomniac Wolverine game made the rounds online extensively, highlighing the ridiculous lengths the game goes to in order to keep you moving down its designated story path (multiple varieties of glowing lines, map markers, voice lines), that all seem unnecessary given that it is a linear corridor-based beat-'em-up.

One well-known reviewer summed it up by saying: "I would argue that the defining characteristic of Marvel's Wolverine is a design philosophy that assumes the player is extremely stupid." Indeed, we can see this elsewhere both within this game (QTEs that autocomplete, automated running sections) and other games (the famous yellow paint debate).

My question is: when did this happen? When did this become such a dominant trend in AAA games? Have the demographics of modern gaming shifted sufficiently that developers genuinely find this level of guidance necessary? Are games now being designed with the assumption that a significant proportion of players will become frustrated or disengaged if they aren't constantly told exactly what to do? Or is this less about the player demographic and more about something happening behind the scenes during development and testing?

I'd be particularly interested to hear from anyone who's worked in QA/UX or playtesting. Is there actually data behind this? For example, do internal playtests show that players regularly get lost in situations where experienced gamers would consider the intended route completely obvious? Do focus testers complain about not knowing where to go, resulting in designers progressively adding more guidance? Or is there some other metric execs pay attention to (completion rates, abandonment, accessibility, time-to-objective, etc.) that encourages this sort of design?

It feels quite different from the way a lot of older games approached the player. There was certainly hand-holding in older games, but there was also much more willingness to simply give you a space, explain the basic mechanics and let you **figure things out yourself.** Metal Gear Solid, Half-Life, Resident Evil, Zelda, Silent Hill, Tomb Raider, etc. could give you objectives and environmental clues without necessarily putting a giant glowing arrow or line over the exact thing you're supposed to interact with. Hell, even one of my examples, Tomb Raider, fell prey to this trend itself in the newer reboot games with Lara's dumbass 'hunter vision' that highlights the intended solution.

And in the new Ocarina of Time remake, much has already been documented about how it has casualized the experience (from what was already a fairly easy game); [here is a thread somebody made ](https://x.com/JJAB91xx/status/2119495468203798995)detailing the numerous changes and edges that have been sanded off to make it a near-frictionless experience that seems to prioritise getting everyone to the credits above all else. What's curious is that pointing this out, at ALL, seems to be a super sore spot surrounding the remake's discourse; in that thread alone, you can see commenters calling him an 'idiot' and that it 'doesn't matter' and that 'nobody will notice.' So clearly there seems to be some layer of defensiveness going on when a game is made this way? Might be interesting to dig into that too if anyone has some insight.

TL;DR: There's something strange about playing a game where the developers have spent millions of dollars creating an environment, filling it with visual details and designing encounters around that environment, only for the game to essentially say: **FOLLOW THE LINE.** It calls to mind the Stanley Parable Adventure Line, which was supposed to be satire!

I'd love to hear from developers about this. Is modern AAA gaming actually responding to players becoming less willing to explore and experiment, or have developers simply become much more afraid of letting players get stuck?

document fetched 2026-11-10 00:25 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1xrmeco/a_question_i_would_like_to_ask_game_devs_from