WTF happened to Emby? Now Jellyfin is better?
retained text
As an Emby lifetime license holder, I switched to Emby after Plex went full enshitification some years ago (am also a Plex lifetime license holder). So I switched to Emby years ago and got a vastly improved playback experience as a result. Fast-forward to now and IDK WTF is going wrong with the Emby devs, but I've been encountering more and more playback issues over the last 6-12 months or so. Namely the absolute abysmal state of subtitle handling (subs just straight up randomly disappearing and re-appearing such that there are entire missing lines, the timings un-syncing to the video etc), and now micro-stutters/lag in video playback itself. Doesn't happen to every file. But enough to be annoying AF. No, I don't know what format the subs are in or what codec the videos are in either, and frankly, none of that is relevant. It should just work as it used to. And no, it's not my hardware either, nor is this a transcoding issue (the files aren't being transcoded in the first place). Of course, I've always been aware of Jellyfin, but I've always relegated it to being a shittier version of Emby. But then I recently saw their 12.0 update dropped, and more importantly, noticed that the Jellyfin devs have vastly improved their database handling. Suspecting that it was actually Emby's internal database management that was actually the source of my problems, I quickly spun up an Jellyfin container and proceeded to test the exact same files that have fucked up playback on Emby, in Jellyfin. Sure enough, they play perfectly fine in Jellyfin and all my subtitle issues disappeared. So...yea... WTF happened to Emby? Just another case of enshitification? Anyone else noticed the general degradation of playback quality on Emby too? **Edit: Figured it out. Turns out Emby has gone to shit on Firefox. Whereas Jellyfin works fine on it. Looks like the Emby devs have stopped developing with Firefox in mind. So I guess I'm moving to Jellyfin.**
document fetched 2026-09-29 00:30 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/selfhosted/comments/1wsgfaf/wtf_happened_to_emby_now_jellyfin_is_better