← sources

Customer received order after shipping delays, insulted product, and wants a refund. How would you handle this?

source: reddit (reddit:EtsySellers)published 2026-10-29 02:53ingested 2026-10-30 02:37

retained text

I’m looking for some advice on how to handle a customer situation because I’ve never experienced anything quite like this.  
I run a small Etsy shop selling custom-designed phone cases, and I take customer service very seriously.  
A customer placed an international order in late September, which was shipped in early October. Unfortunately, the shipment experienced significant delays with the shipping carrier, and tracking stopped updating.  
Throughout the process, I kept the customer informed, checked on the shipment, and provided updates. Although the shipping delays were outside my control, I eventually decided to arrange a complimentary replacement at my own expense because I didn’t want the customer waiting indefinitely.  
I also informed the customer that if the original package eventually arrived, they were welcome to keep it at no additional cost.  
I sent several updates throughout this process, including tracking information for the replacement, but never received a response.  
Today, the customer finally messaged me saying they had received the case. However, neither the original shipment nor the replacement currently shows as delivered on my end.  
Their message stated that the case looked nothing like the listing photographs, described it as “ugly and cheap looking,” claimed it couldn’t be worth more than “50 cents,” and said they would be embarrassed to give it as a gift. They then requested a full refund and said they didn’t want the complimentary replacement.  
I completely understand that customers are entitled to be dissatisfied with a purchase. However, I found the wording unnecessarily disrespectful, especially considering the effort I’d made to resolve the shipping complications.  
For context, the listing includes photographs of the design and a clear disclaimer explaining that decorative effects are professionally printed rather than physically raised. The customer has not provided any photographs of the item they received.  
I’m hesitant to issue a refund without first reviewing the alleged discrepancy, particularly since I’ve already covered the cost of producing and shipping a replacement.  
I’m also concerned about the possibility of an unfair negative review, although I understand that customers have the right to leave honest feedback.

**My questions are:**  
Would you request photographs before considering a refund?  
How would you address the customer’s tone, if at all?  
Would you offer a refund in this situation, given that a complimentary replacement is already in transit?  
Has anyone dealt with an international order where the buyer confirmed receipt but tracking never updated to delivered?

document fetched 2026-10-30 00:25 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/EtsySellers/comments/1xi8jj0/customer_received_order_after_shipping_delays