← sources

First unsatisfied customer - Help please

source: reddit (reddit:EtsySellers)published 2026-09-01 18:10ingested 2026-09-02 02:37

retained text

I'm a new shop owner and I've made a couple hundred sales and have received 100 positive reviews and lots of messages with positive feedback. I've just received some negative feedback and I'm not too sure what to do. 

I sell handmade accessories with a choice of two attachment styles. My listing photos show only one style but I also have an infographic showing both attachment options side by side with pictures and the pros and cons, uses, etc. I also have a little write-up in my description with the two choices and what they are. 

I made the item with the attachment that the customer chose and received a message from her saying that she didn't like it and that there was a misunderstanding. She wanted the other option.

As this was her mistake or misunderstanding, I don't feel like a refund is warranted since I make many attempts at clearly showing what the differences are with the attachment options. But I also appreciate the fact that she messaged me rather than simply leaving a bad review.

The solution is simple because the other choice she can easily add on herself but for me to send it to her it would cost me about $12 which is nearly half my profit. Or she could spend  less than $8 and buy a pack of 10 of these things from Amazon and get it the next day. But I think it's against TOS to suggest she buys something from Amazon right? 

What should I do? How would you handle this?

Edit: customer did NOT ask for a refund. She just wants the other attachment option and I'm asking how best to handle this since this is her mistake but I want to be helpful. Luckily, I do not have to send her an entirely new item - just the attachment piece. There was choice in the variation and she misunderstood and chose the wrong thing. 

document fetched 2026-09-02 00:26 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/EtsySellers/comments/1w4jzg1/first_unsatisfied_customer_help_please