Reddit's Login Requirement aims to stop third-party clients, ad-blockers and unlicensed AI scraping
retained text
Firstly: [you should absolutely read the quarterly report yourself! Like seriously! Do it now!](https://investor.redditinc.com/financials/sec-filings/default.aspx) As of recently it looks like reddit has been blocking off all the workarounds to view the platform without an account. Viewing a post with the `.json` suffix will give a 'network security' error page if not logged in, and there's been the very annoying [but also easily defeated forced login](https://www.reddit.com/r/privacy/comments/1xseui4/removing_the_forced_login_on_reddit_for_now/). I've noticed some other changes that are seemingly being A/B tested (as I got this trying things out on a VM), which instead make it so you can only load 3 posts on a subreddit's page, although post contents are unaffected. this makes it far less usable to normal users, and I'll add that they messed it up to the point it **does basically nothing to bots/scraping**. There is nothing stopping you from reloading with a 'New' sort and scraping a whole post this way, but I expect this to be changed eventually. Overall, if this rolls out there will be **no way** to properly use reddit fully anonymously, even with filters. I actually was with a friend who coincidentally checked a place on reddit and encountered this pop-up literally a few hours after my workaround post, and instead of creating an account or trying some ugly stuff with loading the desktop site with my filter, she just gave up. Which... I think a lot of people are going to do, with most just using AI instead of reddit's website now, which seemed very counter-intuitive. But then I realized this is a public company, and decided to stop speculating and read or something. And after reading the quarterly financial report, this is mainly the result of Reddit wanting to secure sources of revenue from methods like making AI scrapers pay and increasing advertising (foreshadowing). As a publicly traded company this is just to be expected. However this inherently conflicts with the use of third-party clients and ad-blockers, which is where we see that: They are also openly against adblockers in the report... >"We also face intense competition from a wide range of platforms and traditional media, and ongoing advancements in **ad-blocking technology** may undermine the effectiveness of our advertising, further challenging our ability to maintain and grow revenue." (And here's another mention of adblockers and third-party apps even more directly): >"the impact of new technologies or access to Reddit content through **third-party applications** that block or obscure the display of our ads;" And while they're seemingly uncertain of it, they may pursue other AI training/API use contracts beyond what they already have with Google: >We have explored, and will continue to explore, business opportunities in content licensing for purposes including machine learning, business analysis, display, and training generative AI models. The market for content licensing is rapidly evolving, and there is no assurance that we will be able to renew our existing deals and/or enter into new deals on terms satisfactory to us or otherwise be able to sustain or grow revenue from these efforts. So ultimately, they're planning on transitioning Reddit to a walled garden where they can more effectively control advertising to users and the ability to train AI on content, a bit like how Meta does social media. It may not end up as far as everything mentioned, but it's still pretty bad for privacy. And to clear up on R4, I don't know if **every** third-party app or extension is realistically in danger for most users, but reddit has taken a stance against third-party clients that block their marketing, which is an appeal to most alternative clients.
document fetched 2026-11-12 00:39 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/privacy/comments/1xt7zcj/reddits_login_requirement_aims_to_stop_thirdparty