Vakilsearch Filed My Company's Financials for 2 Years Without Filing ADT-1 — Now I'M Paying the Penalties
retained text
Vakilsearch handled my company's ROC compliances for **FY 2023–24 and FY 2024–25**. They filed my company's financials for both years. But here's the unbelievable part: **THEY NEVER FILED ADT-1 FOR THE AUDITOR.** Yes. They were handling and filing my company's financials... **WITHOUT FILING ADT-1 FOR THE AUDITOR.** And this wasn't caught after a few days. Or a few months. **THIS WENT ON FOR TWO F\*\*\*ING YEARS.** How does a professional ROC compliance company handle financial filings for two years without noticing that ADT-1 hasn't been filed? But wait. It gets better. When I wanted to change my auditor, I was informed that **my previous auditor's ADT-3/resignation filing was also pending.** Again — why the f\*\*\* wasn't I told this earlier? I'm not a CA. I'm not a CS. I don't sit on the MCA portal checking whether ADT-1 and ADT-3 have been filed. **THAT'S WHY I F\*\*\*ING HIRED YOU.** So I had to go back to my previous auditor and get the old ADT-3 sorted. And because it was being filed late... **I PAID THE PENALTY FOR THE DELAYED ADT-3.** I got it done and provided the required documents to Vakilsearch on **8 October**. You'd think that after discovering something this serious, they would immediately fix the remaining compliance. Nope. Then started the circus. Emails. Calls. Messages. Follow-ups. More follow-ups. Meanwhile, another statutory deadline is approaching. And now they're finally filing the old **ADT-1 after TWO YEARS.** Guess what? **THERE'S A PENALTY FOR THAT TOO.** So let's understand what happened here: I paid Vakilsearch to handle ROC compliance. **My previous auditor's ADT-3 wasn't filed.** Nobody properly alerted me about it. **Vakilsearch then proceeded with my company's financial filings without filing ADT-1 for the auditor.** Nobody flagged that either. This continued across **two financial years.** I eventually discovered the mess when I wanted to change auditors. I had to coordinate with my previous auditor myself. **I paid the penalty for the delayed ADT-3.** Then I repeatedly chased Vakilsearch to get the ADT-1 sorted. And now... **I'M ALSO PAYING THE PENALTY FOR ADT-1 BEING FILED TWO YEARS LATE.** ARE YOU F\*\*\*ING KIDDING ME? So I paid Vakilsearch to handle my compliance... ...and then I paid penalties because the compliance wasn't handled properly? What an incredible service. **Pay professional fees for compliance.** Then: *"Oops, the previous auditor's form wasn't filed. Please pay the penalty."* Then: *"Oh, ADT-1 wasn't filed either. Another penalty."* Brilliant. At this point, I genuinely have one question: **WHAT THE F\*\*\* DID I PAY VAKILSEARCH FOR?** If I need to personally understand: ADT-1 ADT-3 Auditor appointments Auditor resignations MCA filings SRNs ROC deadlines Late-filing penalties ...then why am I paying a professional compliance company? I might as well become a f\*\*\*ing Company Secretary myself. And before someone says *"mistakes happen"* — Of course mistakes happen. That's not even my biggest problem. My problem is **ACCOUNTABILITY.** If your team discovers that: 1. The previous auditor's ADT-3 wasn't filed, and 2. You subsequently handled the company's financial filings without filing ADT-1, shouldn't somebody say: **"We screwed up. We'll fix it immediately and take responsibility for the penalties caused by our lapse."** Instead? I'm chasing support like they're doing me a favour. **I'M THE F\*\*\*ING CUSTOMER.** I paid you specifically so I wouldn't have to worry about ROC compliance. And now I'm spending my time learning ADT-1 and ADT-3 because apparently I need to verify whether the professionals I hired actually did their job. So here's my advice to every founder using Vakilsearch or ANY online compliance platform: **NEVER blindly trust that your compliance is complete just because they tell you it is.** Ask for every filed form. Ask for every SRN. Check MCA yourself. Verify that your auditor was actually appointed. Verify that your previous auditor actually resigned. Keep your own compliance tracker. Because apparently you need to **audit the people you hired to handle your f\*\*\*ing compliance.** Based on my experience, I would **never trust Vakilsearch with my company's ROC compliance again.** They handled my company's financial filings for **two financial years without filing ADT-1.** My previous auditor's **ADT-3 was also pending.** **I paid the penalty to get ADT-3 filed.** Now **ADT-1 is being filed two years late, and I'm paying another penalty.** And I've had to repeatedly chase them while another statutory deadline approaches. Absolutely f\*\*\*ing ridiculous. **Any other founders here had a similar experience with Vakilsearch?** I'd genuinely like to know whether I got spectacularly unlucky or whether others have faced the same kind of mess.
document fetched 2026-10-14 00:46 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/IndiaTax/comments/1x51jla/vakilsearch_filed_my_companys_financials_for_2