← sources

Prebuilt NAS or custom build? Immich + Jellyfin + a few web projects, been going back and forth for weeks

source: reddit (reddit:selfhosted)published 2026-09-28 12:23ingested 2026-09-29 02:40

retained text

Hey,

Finally pulling the trigger on a home server and I could use some outside perspective, because I've been going in circles for weeks.

Context: web dev, need to get my photos off Google Photos and self-host them. Immich for photos, Jellyfin for media, and I want to move a few personal projects off my VPS (Node APIs, Postgres, crons). Proxmox on top, all open source. Nothing heavy, but I want room to grow.

Problem is, with RAM and drive prices right now, every calculation I make falls apart. I've spent way too many evenings in spreadsheets and I keep landing on the same three options.

Option A: a prebuilt x86 NAS. I've looked at the Minisforum N5 Air (\~€570 barebone, \~€770 with 16GB, Ryzen 7 255, 5 bays, 10GbE), the UGREEN DXP4800 Plus/Pro, and the Aoostar WTR Pro which is way cheaper but AliExpress-only with a fuzzy warranty. Compact, quiet, order it and I'm done. Downside: paying peak DDR5 prices, 2 RAM slots, and if the board dies the whole thing is landfill.

Option B: an Intel 12th/13th gen DDR4 build (thinking i5-12400 + B760 DDR4 + Node 304). On paper it fits me better: Quick Sync and OpenVINO are better supported than the AMD path for Jellyfin and Immich, 4 RAM slots, DDR4 still findable used for reasonable money, standard parts I can swap one by one for the next decade. Downside: hunting for deals for weeks, no 10GbE out of the box, and being my own RMA department.

Option C: a used SFF (OptiPlex / EliteDesk 10th gen) as a cheap starting point, which I'd probably outgrow.

I'm in France, budget is roughly €600-1000 including drives, and that last part is really my question: where's the sweet spot right now between "cheap out and regret it in 18 months" and "overspend on hardware I'll never load"? Prices being what they are, I'd rather not throw money at specs I don't need.

So:

Anyone who went the custom route, would you do it again? Or did the time sink and the noise end up not being worth it?

Anyone running an N5 Air or similar (Aoostar WTR Pro, UGREEN)? Does it hold up long term? Is Minisforum support as hit or miss as people say?

Am I overestimating how much CPU I need? Would something more modest handle 5-6 containers alongside Immich just fine?

Where would you draw the line between future-proof and overkill for this kind of workload?

And if there's a fourth option I haven't considered, I'm all ears.

Thanks

document fetched 2026-09-29 00:30 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/selfhosted/comments/1wsd5mn/prebuilt_nas_or_custom_build_immich_jellyfin_a