Nvidia is down 32% since Oct 6. I checked 2,943 similar drops in big US stocks to see if buying them paid
retained text
Nvidia closed at 162.85 on Friday. On Oct 6 it was 239.24. That is -31.9%. Every time a big name drops like this, half the comments say "buy the dip" and the other half say "falling knife". I wanted numbers. The test: \- 500 most traded US stocks, Oct 2017 – Aug 2026, delisted ones included \- Signal: a stock fell 15% or more in 10 trading days while the broad market was calm (equal-weight index above its 200-day average and not down more than 2% over those 10 days) \- Buy at the next open, sell at the close 20 trading days later, 0.10% costs \- Compared with a random day in the same stock, same year, same calm-market condition Result, 2,943 cases: \- Average after 20 days: -0.29%. Median: -1.33%. 45.8% of cases ended in plus. \- A random day in the same stock: +0.90% on average. \- The gap is -1.19 points, with a 95% range from -3.41 to +1.18. So the honest reading is "no edge", not "proven worse". \- Against a random other stock on the same day the gap is -0.64 points (range -2.19 to +1.06). Same story. \- Buying the drop beat the random day in 4 of 10 years. Two splits (neither is statistically significant): \- Sharp drops, with one day of -8% or worse: 2,161 cases, gap -2.17 points (range -4.67 to +0.25) \- Slow drops without such a day: 782 cases, gap +1.53 points (range -1.06 to +4.18) Before you ask: \- No survivorship bias, delisted stocks are in. \- The stocks that trigger this most often are volatile names like RIOT, MARA and MRNA. Nvidia is not a typical case here. \- Years differ a lot. 2022 had only 31 cases and they averaged -12.5%. \- My first control was wrong. I compared with random days from the whole year, including days when the market filter was off. That made buying the drop look much worse (-2.90 points). The numbers above are after the fix. One live case. This rule triggered on Nvidia on Nov 9. Entry at the open on Nov 10 was 173.97. At Friday's close that is -6.4%. The 20 days end on Dec 8, and I'll come back with the result either way. One case proves nothing. Historical test, not advice. Do you buy sharp drops in names you like, or do you wait?
document fetched 2026-11-17 00:44 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/StockMarket/comments/1xxzfpu/nvidia_is_down_32_since_oct_6_i_checked_2943