← sources

I cold-emailed 119 small streamers. 10 replied, but only 3 said yes. Here's what I learned.

source: reddit (reddit:gamedev)published 2026-11-11 13:44ingested 2026-11-12 02:38

retained text

I do marketing at a small indie studio with two demos on Steam: a Cold War codebreaking game and a clicker game. Over two and a half weeks I emailed 119 YouTube, Twitch and Kick creators.  
  
On paper that's an 8% reply rate. In reality:  
\- 3 said yes (one had already put our game in his Next Fest top 25 video)  
\- 3 asked for paid rates  
\- 2 said no  
\- 2 were automatic or agency replies  
  
What I learned:  
  
1. Small channels answer. Channels with 1K to 10K subscribers replied most: 6 of 36 (17%). Above 10K it dropped to 3 of 57 (5%), and 2 of those 3 replies were rate cards. Under 1K: 0 of 11.  
  
2. Count yeses, not replies. A reply asking for money looks like a win on a dashboard but isn't one on a small budget.  
  
3. The game matters more than the email. Same email structure for both games: the clicker got 9 replies from 93 emails, the codebreaking game 1 from 26. A fast, reactive game seems to be an easier yes for a streamer.  
  
4. Platforms: Kick 2 of 17, YouTube 7 of 81, Twitch 1 of 21. Small samples, so I wouldn't read much into it yet.  
  
The email structure (under 150 words):  
\- One line about a specific video they made on a similar game  
\- Two sentences on what makes the game fun to film  
\- The free demo link  
\- A full-game key at launch plus 5 keys for their viewers  
\- "No need to reply if it's not a fit"  
  
I automated finding the channels, drafting and sending with n8n and Gemini. It costs about €8 a month and 15 minutes a day. Happy to explain the setup in the comments.  
  
Questions for you:  
1. Do you pay small creators? What's a fair rate for a 5K to 30K channel?  
2. Has a follow-up email ever worked for you, or does it just annoy people?

document fetched 2026-11-12 00:26 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1xti3j1/i_coldemailed_119_small_streamers_10_replied_but