← sources

Smaller mirrored drives or 1 large drive?

source: reddit (reddit:homelab)published 2026-09-30 08:38ingested 2026-10-01 02:43

retained text

I just have to ask this question because its keeping my up. I plan to run Proxmox for this server.

Before I setup my current home lab, I only have smr drives, but I've decided to go for cmr drives. This is where im stuck, I know I might not use a whole lot of storage on my drives so im considering just going for new 4tb hdds that are $189 USD each. In total I would be spending $412 after tax and shipping on Amazo for 2 of them.

Compared to the 8tb, it would only be $358 on Amazon for a single one.

Is it worth spending more for only 4tb of storage but I can use RAID or just go for a single 8tb for less but only have 1 drive? 

I do have 2x 2tb Barracudda drives at the moment. Should I just buy a 4tb cmr drives and treat the extra 2tb as separate backups?

Any help or ideas will be appreciated!

document fetched 2026-10-01 00:40 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/homelab/comments/1wtznbf/smaller_mirrored_drives_or_1_large_drive