← sources

Every subscription gives roughly $11-12 per dollar spent on the sub weekly

source: reddit (reddit:ClaudeAI)published 2026-10-30 15:46ingested 2026-10-31 02:36

retained text

So I made a post the other day asking if there was any downside to using Max 20 vs Max 5 / Pro. I was informed that the 20x and 5x only applied to the 5 hr limits, not the weekly.

So having had a few accounts over the last few weeks and using my history prior I had claude anaylze all of the accounts along with the rough equiv of API costs.

I ended up with these costs per reset:



Est. API Cost | Sub Cost | Weekly Used | API cost / Dollar
---|---|----|----
2278 | 200 | 100 | 11.39
2281 | 200 | 100 | 11.41
2386 | 200 | 100 | 11.93
1179 | 100 | 100 | 11.79
1187 | 100 | 100 | 11.87
1153 | 100 | 100 | 11.53
230 | 20 | 95 | 12.11
105 | 20 | 41 | 12.80

The Pro accounts are new and haven't been 100% used on the weekly so I used their usage % * sub cost instead, so one was ~$19 and the other ~$8.20

So basically every sub has the same worth which was interesting. I was told that the Pro / Max 5 was actually a better deal than the Max 20 but they look very similar.

On the Max 20 plan:

* $8757.22 (97.6%) Opus 5.5
* $136.40 (1.6%) Fable 5.1
* $71.39 (0.8%) Sonnet 5.5
* $1.66 (0.0% heh) of Haiku 5.5

On the Max 5 plan:

* $3478 (98%) Opus 5.5
* $25.65 (0.7%) Fable 5.1
* $16.80 (0.5%) Opus 5
* $0.39 (0.0%) Haiku 5.5

So basically... if you want the best bang/buck, they are all about the same. If there were more resets given, the Pro accounts would be best since you could have more of them at the same total price.

$200 Max 20 gives you roughly $2300 weekly
$100 Max 5 gives you roughly $1200 weekly
$20 Pro gives you roughly $240 weekly

And tracking the limit -> Weekly % was roughly 12-14% on the Pro accounts, I wasn't able to back track this for the Max accounts because they were already at weekly limits by the time I'd had claude make the tracking tool.

But for Pro accounts roughly 5hr limit is worth $35 and weekly $240

Edit:

Anthropic today updated their naming, its now just "Max" and "Ultra". They also verified that Max is 5x Pro and Ultra is 10x Pro which lines up with my testing.

I also checked the team pricing and it also lines up with their monthly costs of $25 and $125 being 1.25x Pro and 6.25x Pro.

document fetched 2026-10-31 00:22 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/ClaudeAI/comments/1xjiwiq/every_subscription_gives_roughly_1112_per_dollar