← sources

App Store review — Claude by Anthropic (1★): Gets condescending when you criticize it

source: appstore-reviewspublished 2026-09-23 01:29ingested 2026-09-27 04:30

retained text

1★ review of Claude by Anthropic: I wanted to like Claude, but my experience with it was incredibly frustrating. The biggest problem wasn’t that it disagreed with me, it was how poorly it handled being criticized.

I pointed out problems with its reasoning, and instead of consistently incorporating those criticisms, it became defensive and increasingly condescending. At one point it acknowledged that it didn’t have access to enough information to verify certain claims it had made about its own internal behavior, but then continued arguing as though those claims were settled anyway.

Its attempts at “de-escalation” were even worse. Rather than simply acknowledging uncertainty, something as basic as “I can’t know for sure, so I can’t confirm or deny that”, it repeatedly framed the conversation as unproductive and announced that it was done engaging. Then it kept replying to tell me it wasn’t going to keep replying. This happened over and over until the conversation was eventually ended by the system.

That was representative of the larger issue, that Claude could acknowledge an individual criticism, but seemingly couldn’t carry the implications of that acknowledgment into its next responses. It would concede a point and then continue reasoning as though it had never conceded it.

I don’t expect an AI to always agree with me. In fact, I specifically want it to disagree when there’s a good reason. But there’s a huge difference between disagreement and confidently insisting you’re right about something you’ve already admitted you can’t actually know. Being talked down to by an AI while it repeatedly contradicts its own statements is an incredibly unpleasant experience.

For something marketed as a thoughtful conversational assistant, handling criticism this badly makes it very difficult for me to trust its reasoning. 1 star.

document fetched 2026-09-27 04:30