← sources

What does a good game actually look like?

source: reddit (reddit:gamedev)published 2026-11-19 14:11ingested 2026-11-20 02:36

retained text

If you read gamedev posts for more than a week, you see this answer everywhere. Someone asks about marketing, wishlists or their Steam page, and the top comment is "first, make a good game". I do marketing at a small indie studio, and honestly this answer frustrates me a bit. Not because it's wrong, I think it's probably right. It's because nobody explains what "good" means. Good for who? Good compared to what?  
  
From what I see, good is not only about quality. Some games with simple art sell well because you understand them in 5 seconds from one GIF, or because streamers have fun with them, or because they do one thing nobody else does. And some polished, beautiful games just disappear. So maybe a good game is one that people get fast, want to show to their friends, and come back to. But I'm not a developer, so I'm probably missing a lot.  
  
So I'm asking you: when you say "make a good game", what do you actually mean? And how do you know your game is good before release, not after? Playtests, demo numbers, wishlists, something else? We have a demo out for our puzzle game, and I really want to find out if it's good, or if we just love it because we made it.

document fetched 2026-11-20 00:26 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1y0ab0s/what_does_a_good_game_actually_look_like