How would you handle a return request on a large personalized order?
retained text
**TL;DR:** Customer placed a \~$400 order for 64 personalized items. The listing states the material is PLA/plastic and my shop doesn’t accept returns. After receiving them, the customer said they looked/felt too artificial and flimsy, wouldn’t want to keep them in the house, and didn’t feel comfortable giving them as gifts. There is no damage or defect. Since the items were made specifically for her, I’m concerned that accepting the return would leave me with 64 personalized pieces I can’t easily resell. **Would you accept the return, offer a partial refund, or decline it?** I’m a fairly new Etsy seller and would really appreciate some unbiased opinions from other sellers. I recently received a large order of around **64 personalized items**, totaling about $400. The customer selected the designs/colors, and I made the entire order specifically according to their requests. The listing states the **material as PLA/plastic** and includes the dimensions and intended use. My shop policy also says that I don’t accept returns or exchanges. Because it was such a large order, I also included an additional item as a free goodwill gift. After receiving the order, the customer contacted me saying they were very disappointed with the quality. They said the items felt/looked too flimsy and artificial for what they intended to use them for and asked to return the entire order. I asked whether there was any damage or defect because I wanted to understand the issue. They confirmed there was **no damage**. They then explained that the items looked very artificial/3D-printed to them and were not what they expected in terms of quality. They said they wouldn’t even want to keep the items in their house and felt they couldn’t give them as gifts. I explained that the listing does disclose the material as PLA/plastic and that the order was made specifically according to their requested designs. My dilemma is that if I accept the return, I’m potentially left with **64 personalized items that were made specifically for this customer**, along with all the material, labor, and production costs. I don’t want to be unreasonable because I understand that the customer may genuinely be disappointed. At the same time, I don’t feel comfortable accepting a return on a large personalized order when there is no damage or defect. **What would you do in this situation?** Would you decline the return, offer some kind of goodwill refund, or accept the return anyway? I’m genuinely looking for opinions from both sides rather than just validation. **If you were the buyer, would you feel the seller should accept the return? If you were the seller, what would you do?**
document fetched 2026-10-01 00:28 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/EtsySellers/comments/1wuj057/how_would_you_handle_a_return_request_on_a_large