My reviewers keep asking why and the honest answer is Codex decided
retained text
I use Codex for most of my work now and review has gotten awkward. Someone asks "why a map here instead of a list" or "why catch this error and not that one" and the true answer is that Codex picked it and I agreed because it looked fine. I've started guessing a reason on the spot so I don't look like I didn't read my own PR. Last week I did that on 3 comments in one review and got one of them wrong. So i got three questions: Does anyone else end up making up reasons after the fact? Do you tell reviewers "the agent chose this", or is that a bad look? What do you do so you actually know why before you open the PR?
document fetched 2026-10-28 00:20 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/AI_Agents/comments/1xgmou4/my_reviewers_keep_asking_why_and_the_honest