← sources

Spent months developing a game idea I thought was unique, then discovered someone has just released the exact same game idea

source: reddit (reddit:gamedev)published 2026-09-27 17:59ingested 2026-09-28 02:38

retained text

Had a bit of a gut punch today

I've been developing a game for the past few months that I genuinely thought had a fairly unique premise: a Roman gladiator management/auto-battler where you play as a lanista, buy and train slaves/gladiators, equip them, enter them into fights and gradually build up your ludus.

Mine is a 3D game with first/third-person exploration. You physically walk around the ludus, marketplace and fighting venues, interact with your gladiators and watch/command fights from the sidelines.

Today I randomly discovered another upcoming game that has an extremely similar core concept: Roman setting, managing a ludus, buying gladiators, training/equipping them and sending them into automated fights. Theirs is a 2D/pixel-art management game, so the actual presentation and player experience are very different, but seeing the feature overlap was still pretty horrible.

I've never seen their game before and I've never publicly shared mine, so it's clearly just two developers independently arriving at a similar idea. I also have months of Git history and design documents from before I discovered it, so I'm not concerned about proving where my work came from.

What bothers me more is perception. By the time I eventually release mine, their game will presumably have been public for much longer, and I'm worried people will see mine and assume "oh, this is just a 3D version of that game" when I've been building it independently all along.

I'm curious whether anyone else has experienced this. Did discovering a similar game change your plans, or did you just keep building the version you wanted to make?

document fetched 2026-09-28 00:26 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1wrqw0c/spent_months_developing_a_game_idea_i_thought_was