← sources

Civil engineer here. Claude is incredibly powerful in my field, but using AI is practically taboo. Is it like this in other industries ?

source: reddit (reddit:ClaudeAI)published 2026-11-01 19:28ingested 2026-11-02 02:37

retained text

I’m a civil engineer and own a small municipal engineering firm. I also do forensic engineering, including expert work for legal cases.

I use Claude, and it’s honestly shocking how powerful it is for this kind of work. Civil engineering is a conservative industry, but contrary to what people might imagine, a huge amount of the work is repetitive. There is enormous potential for automation that’s barely being touched.

What has surprised me most is how strong Claude is in forensic engineering. It can help me work through a case by building a coherent chain of reasoning, developing hypotheses, and exploring their implications. It can go remarkably far with that reasoning, not just summarize a document or rewrite a paragraph. Yes, you need to verify the output at the end. But the amount of work you can automate or substantially accelerate is huge.

Yet bringing this up with other engineers is practically taboo. I get dismissed, downvoted on Reddit, or told that using AI must mean I’m a bad engineer. The responses are usually some version of “AI is useless,” “it hallucinates,” or “it will never have an engineer’s judgment.”

Most engineers I talk to seem convinced they’re irreplaceable. The conversation often feels less like a discussion about what the technology can actually do and more like a reaction to the idea that their work could be automated. I wonder how much of it is insecurity or fear of being replaced. It almost becomes a question of personal worth rather than a discussion about the tool.

And when I ask what they’re basing their opinion on, it often turns out they’re talking about Copilot or the free version of ChatGPT they tried in 2024. They haven’t explored agentic AI or seen what Claude can actually do in civil engineering. But they’ve already decided what its limits are.

For my firm, that’s a huge competitive advantage. There’s an incredibly powerful tool available, and much of my industry won’t seriously look at it.  
Is this happening in other traditional industries too ? Are you seeing the same disconnect between what you’re actually doing with Claude and what your colleagues believe is possible ? Why do you think the resistance is so strong ?

And why isn’t Anthropic doing more to showcase these applications outside coding ? Claude seems overwhelmingly marketed as a coding tool, while in civil engineering it’s massively underused despite the automation potential. The people dismissing it often don’t even seem aware of what they’re dismissing.

It feels like this is going to create a huge gap, not just between people who use AI and people who don’t, but between people who understand what these tools can do and people who think their experience with a basic chatbot tells them everything.

document fetched 2026-11-02 00:21 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/ClaudeAI/comments/1xlc0v6/civil_engineer_here_claude_is_incredibly_powerful