Have you moved away from self-hosting towards commercial products or cloud services?
retained text
My current stack is Linux + Ansible + Docker Compose for multiple machines and services that I host. For years I tried to maximize control and use open-source software wherever possible.
A lot of that came from the scandals around proprietary software and cloud services in the 2000s/2010s, plus videos of people like Richard Stallman convincing me that free software is the way to go. I still largely agree with that philosophy.
But lately I've started questioning whether I am too strict about it, costing me more than I benefit.
A few things changed my thinking:
- The last half year, I really spent a lot of time "ansibleizing" my whole setup. While this was a good learning experience, I find it harder and harder to explain why I put so much effort into this for a few simple services that are less convenience than free services they see elsewhere.
- I realized, if someone asked me for advice, I would probably not recommend replicating my own setup. It is simply too much work, with too many moving parts and too many ways something can break.
- I used to believe FOSS was inherently more secure. I'm much less convinced now. The Coldcard vulnerability coverage influenced me here: even highly security-critical open-source software was apparently not reviewed enough by the community. Meanwhile, commercial vendors can have dedicated security teams, audits, bug bounties, etc. -- I feel the security landscape changed over the last decade(s).
- Commercial products and cloud services often win massively on usability and maintenance.
- Something like Synology seems like an interesting middle ground: proprietary software, but local storage, normal files, and standard interfaces such as SMB, SSH and WebDAV.
- I'm also thinking about legacy. My current setup is understandable mainly to me. Even with documentation, if I were suddenly unable to maintain it, my realistic handover plan would be: "Here is the documentation; find a competent Linux admin *somewhere*."
So I'm reconsidering my almost religious "FOSS first" position.
Has anyone here gone through the same transition - away from maximizing self-hosting/open source and towards commercial products or cloud services? Did you regret it, or did it help?document fetched 2026-08-28 11:15 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/selfhosted/comments/1w01zv8/have_you_moved_away_from_selfhosting_towards