Isn't it animals deserve a fair chance of discussion in Parliament before implementing something like this?
retained text
My post isn't against any political parties, because I am aware that Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act, 1960 is already exist long before. Also I know, any changes to the existing act is not necessarily required parliament discussion. But we are using other living beings for our benefit. Isn't it fair to discuss at least once before making any changes to existing one? I am looking for fair and practical discussion on the recent amendments made in Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (Control and Supervision of Experiment, Breeding and Trading of Laboratory Animals) Rules, 2026 which eases the animal experiments. NOT AN EMOTIONAL ONE, SOME USEFUL POV FROM FELLOW REDDITORS. Here are the changes incase someone is curious to analyze what is happening around. |Issue|Existing framework|Proposed 2026 rules| |:-|:-|:-| |Experiment approvals|Largely based on animal size|Based on expected pain and suffering| |Large animals|Generally require central approval|Mild/moderate experiments can receive institutional approval| |Monkeys|Subject to strict restrictions|Conditional use permitted| |Wild animals|Restricted|Exceptions possible with permission| |Stray animals|Restricted|Certain exceptions permitted| |Animal welfare|Existing care and procedural safeguards|New 3Rs principles, but some existing protections altered| |Animal / species|Before (existing rules)|Proposed 2026 rules|Effect| |:-|:-|:-|:-| |Tiger|Highly protected; wildlife permissions required|Protected; narrow conditional exceptions under Rule 5|Conditional route| |Asian elephant|Highly protected; wildlife permissions required|Protected; narrow conditional exceptions|Conditional route| |Indian leopard|Highly protected; wildlife permissions required|Protected; narrow conditional exceptions|Conditional route| |Lion|Highly protected; wildlife permissions required|Protected; narrow conditional exceptions|Conditional route| |Indian pangolin|Highly protected; wildlife permissions required|Protected; narrow conditional exceptions|Conditional route| |Rhesus macaque (monkey)|Wildlife restrictions and central experiment approval generally apply|Listed protected primates remain prohibited under Rule 6(2)|Explicit prohibition| |Hanuman langur|Wildlife restrictions and central experiment approval generally apply|Listed protected primates remain prohibited|Explicit prohibition| |Stray dogs|Strict restrictions on laboratory sourcing|Exemptions possible for essential research|Potential relaxation| |Stray cats|Strict restrictions on laboratory sourcing|Exemptions possible for essential research|Potential relaxation| |Wild birds|Wildlife protections and permissions apply|Conditional exceptions for protected or wild-caught animals|Conditional route| |Laboratory dogs|Experiments generally require central approval|IAEC can approve mild/moderate experiments|Reduced central oversight| |Laboratory rabbits|IAEC approval generally sufficient|IAEC approval generally remains sufficient|Limited change| |Laboratory mice/rats|IAEC approval generally sufficient|IAEC approval generally remains sufficient|Limited change|
document fetched 2026-10-20 00:26 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/india/comments/1x9tqui/isnt_it_animals_deserve_a_fair_chance_of