← sources

We chose €15 one-time instead of a subscription for our app. Tell me why we're wrong

source: reddit (reddit:SaaS)published 2026-10-25 16:25ingested 2026-10-26 02:37

retained text

Two of us are about to sell a native Mac app that turns your Apple Music library into a map you explore. Every pricing thread here says "go subscription". We didn't, and I'd like this sub to poke holes in our reasoning.



\*\*Why one-time (€15)\*\*



\- Our users already pay for a subscription: Apple Music. Asking for a second one to browse the first felt hard to justify.

\- Our costs barely grow with users. There's no account and no backend holding user data: the app talks to Apple Music directly. What we pay for is the payment provider's fee, the Apple developer account and the website.

\- Mac users have a long habit of paying once for indie apps, and "no subscription" is a selling point in itself on that market.



\*\*The middle ground we picked\*\*



\- Lifetime license, with every update released in your first year

\- After that, the app keeps working on the last version you received

\- Full refund within 7 days, no free trial (yet)



\*\*The stack, if it helps anyone\*\*



\- Polar as merchant of record: it handles VAT, receipts and emails the license key

\- Sparkle for in-app updates, the .dmg hosted on GitHub releases

\- PostHog on the site, with the purchase tied back to the visit when the visitor accepts cookies



\*\*What scares us\*\*



1. No recurring revenue means we need new buyers every month, forever. At what point did one-time pricing stop working for you, if you tried it?

2. Paid upgrades later (v2), or a cheaper "renew updates" price after the first year?

3. No free trial: are we killing our conversion? We have a 7-day refund and a browser demo instead.



Not dropping a link, I'm genuinely after the debate. Happy to share numbers after launch.

document fetched 2026-10-26 00:27 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/SaaS/comments/1xf6q0j/we_chose_15_onetime_instead_of_a_subscription_for