Yay, our first publishing offer! They only wanted 55% of our revenue! :D
retained text
For a little background: We're a team of five student indie devs from Finland working on a pinball roguelike called PINBOMB. We currently have around 1,500 wishlists and have been planning to self-publish from the start. Recently, a legitimate (albeit small) indie publisher approached us on Discord, interested in publishing our game. They presented what they called their "standard deal": **45% for us, 55% for them.** And what would we get for that? Well, a long list of things they *could* do. Marketing, localization, PR, influencers, community management, you name it. Funding was possible too, but then something other than the “standard deal” would be agreed. They offered both worldwide and Asia-focused publishing, although their expertise seemed to be mostly in China, Japan, and Korea. Now, I'm also a lawyer by day, and I've seen my fair share of questionable deals. Usually I'm the one cleaning up the mess after someone has signed something they really shouldn't have. So naturally I was not particularly excited about what I was hearing. However, out of morbid professional curiosity to be on this side of the table for once and just to see what would happen, I wanted to push further and see what this deal actually entails and where exactly they’d try to screw us over (other than taking most of our revenue). So I asked what specific marketing activities and investments they'd guarantee. After all, if we're giving someone half of our sales, I'd imagine they'd have to promise to do something in return. Their response was that marketing depends on how the game performs, and: *"Since marketing strategies need to adapt to the market as we gather more data, it's difficult for us to guarantee a specific activities or investment amount."* Okay, fair enough. Marketing plans change. But surely there would be something in the actual publishing contract about what they'd have to do? Thus I asked them. Their response? *"We generally don't include a minimum marketing spend in the agreements."* They'd also described their publisher agreement signing process like so: *“If we decide to move forward, the typical process would be: agreement → planning the publishing strategy → development continues while we prepare marketing, localization, and distribution → regular communication around key milestones.”* They did say they could outline planned marketing activities in the contract, but the actual budget would depend on how the game performs. But "marketing" means absolutely nothing if there's no minimum amount of it you have to do. You can write "social media promotion, influencer outreach and community management" into a contract, but if you don't specify how much, what's stopping the publisher from making a couple of social media posts, contacting a few influencers and calling it a day? Depending on how the agreement is written, they could theoretically do the bare minimum and still take half the revenue. Obviously, I'm not saying that's what this particular publisher would do, but it's exactly the kind of thing I'd want to have figured out before signing anything. Oh, and when discussing a guaranteed minimum marketing budget, they told us they'd need to discuss a "corresponding minimum sales commitment from the developer". I found that one particularly funny. I'd be genuinely interested in hearing how they'd imagine that working in practice. Now, to be fair, after some back and forth, their offer did get considerably better. They proposed a 50/50 split that would only apply to sales in China, Japan and Korea, and we'd keep everything from the rest of the world. They'd also pay their own marketing costs without taking those expenses out of the revenue before splitting it. That's definitely a lot more reasonable than the initial 55% proposal, which hadn't even specified the territories. I'm not calling them scammers. They, at least for now, were completely transparent about their outrageous deal. But I still find it pretty wild that a publisher could potentially take 50% of your sales in a region without specifying how they’d be promoting the game. Maybe the actual contract would have more concrete obligations, but I certainly didn't get much clarity on that. I never intended to take the deal, but the whole conversation got me wondering how common this sort of thing is. Have any of you received similar publishing offers? Or actually signed deals where the publisher promised the world but ended up barely doing anything? I'm especially interested in hearing from people who have actually worked with publishers that did not specify marketing commitments beforehand. What did they promise you? What did they actually end up doing? And was it worth the cut they took? Anyway, be careful folks. Read your contracts. Run them by a lawyer. Don't get too excited and sign something just because a publisher noticed your game. Or at least ask Reddit (or your mom) first. **TL;DR:** Publisher approached us with a standard 45/55 split in their favor. After some back and forth, they offered 50/50 for sales in China, Japan and Korea, with no upfront funding and no guaranteed minimum marketing budget. I'm still not sure what they'd actually be required to do for their half. Here’s a Steam link of our game for convenience: [https://store.steampowered.com/app/4869310/PINBOMB/](https://store.steampowered.com/app/4869310/PINBOMB/)
document fetched 2026-11-10 00:25 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1xrro6j/yay_our_first_publishing_offer_they_only_wanted