I was tech chair for ICCV 2021. Here's my Defense of Academic Gatekeeping.
retained text
I was tech chair for ICCV 2021, and had "root access" to the whole process, so I saw (and scrubbed) its barnacly underbelly. The ICCV organization tried to combat fraud, plagiarism, and cheating, but it was not a fair fight. There were at that point no effective mechanisms for detecting and punishing authors who tried to gain an unfair advantage. Academic ML needs better policies. And we need to get this right because society needs better ways to build consensus and seek truth. I wrote this essay to share some meta-science analysis I did over the last few weeks on academic ML and a few policy ideas. My hope is to engage in discussion about academic ML policy. I believe that the only way we make progress on this is to sample and refine ideas together. So I ask: what are the policies you'd like to see adopted by academic journals and conferences? Full essay: [https://lacuna.tiptreesystems.com/paper/a-defense-of-academic-gatekeeping/art\_221912b72e224a4393c508d4dd3ce5ed](https://lacuna.tiptreesystems.com/paper/a-defense-of-academic-gatekeeping/art_221912b72e224a4393c508d4dd3ce5ed) (I'm now a postdoc-entrepreneur at Mila with Hugo Larochelle and Chris Pal, working on meta-science, multi-agent games, and AI for science.)
document fetched 2026-11-19 00:23 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/computervision/comments/1xzgpf3/i_was_tech_chair_for_iccv_2021_heres_my_defense