← sources

18 signups in 2 months: what worked and what flopped for my SaaS

source: reddit (reddit:EntrepreneurRideAlong)published 2026-10-02 06:33ingested 2026-10-03 02:37

retained text

About two months ago I launched a small SaaS. You paste a Reddit post, pick the subreddit, and it tells you if the post is likely to get removed and why. Not linking it, this is just an honest update.

I built it because I do a lot of Reddit marketing, and posts getting removed without me noticing kept wasting my time. You think nobody cared, when really nobody saw it.

Building it went fine. Next.js, Supabase, one DigitalOcean box. The embarrassing part came later. The first version ran the whole scoring engine in the browser, so anyone could open devtools and read exactly how it worked. I moved it server-side and put a few hundred tests around it.

Getting people to use it has been way harder. At one point in August I went a full week with zero new signups, so I started trying channels.

First Reddit ads. **I spent $125, got 61 clicks and 0 signups.**

Google ads I never even ran. The whole search volume for this problem is around 700 searches a month in the US, so there was nothing to buy.

Then email. About 500 emails to a list of Reddit marketers. 480 delivered, 6 clicked, 1 signed up, and that person never ran a check. In the last batch 6 people unsubscribed and only 3 clicked. I did fix one thing: my first batches bounced at 6-7% because I was mailing the oldest part of the list first. Going newest first dropped it to 0.4%. Clicks didn't move though.

What surprised me is where the real users came from. None of the people using it came from the email. A few of them come back and run several checks. One person checked the same draft three times, fixing it in between: 80, then 85, then 100. That's exactly the loop I built it for, and it came from someone I never reached out to.

Two other things I changed:

* I was worried people would farm free checks with throwaway Gmail accounts, so I made the basic verdict free and unlimited and only charge for the AI rewrite. Not much left worth farming.
* I built rules pages for 150+ subreddits, mostly for Google. Impressions went from about 5 a day to 130 a day in a month. Clicks are still tiny.

Revenue so far: **$0**.

Next I'm talking to the handful of people who actually use it, and posting here what I learn instead of paying for attention. This is the first one.

Question for anyone who's been at this stage: at 480 emails and 6 clicks, would you keep testing email, or put that time into the 5 people already using it?

document fetched 2026-10-03 00:25 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/EntrepreneurRideAlong/comments/1wvmnoq/18_signups_in_2_months_what_worked_and_what