← sources

New dev, next fest and AI ramblings

source: reddit (reddit:gamedev)published 2026-10-23 18:32ingested 2026-10-24 02:37

retained text

I am a fairly new game developer about to release my first commercial game. I have been developing games for 2.5 years now and this commercial game has been in the works for \~ 20 months.

Going into game dev, I had programming experience, but very minimal art experience, and one of my initial plans was to create a card game to leverage AI assets while devoting my time to the mechanics and balance. The game dev community here talked me down from this idea, insisting that it would fail on the merit of using AI, so I made all of the assets myself and spent lots of time and energy learning the art side as I don't have funding to hire professionals for asset creation.

Fast forward to the ongoing next fest, and there are many games which fully use AI assets and code out-competing and burying my fully human made game. I think at this point my game's discoverability on next nest has dropped to zero.

I don't think it is fair or honest at this point to recommend a new developer to take this same fully-human made path as I did, when the competition is making use of AI which seems to completely outclass amateur, human-made art. No doubt if you come from an art background there is more advantage to creating your own, and this likely still outcompetes the purely AI stuff.

What is the community take on what we're seeing with this next fest? 

In case you are interested in an example that I am comparing my game with, here is my steam demo, and an AI made demo which is out-competing mine in the same genre space:

Mine: https://store.steampowered.com/app/5415680/Booty\_Battler\_Demo/

A more successful demo: https://store.steampowered.com/app/5056220/Deck\_Beasts\_Demo/

I want to stress there is no shade to the creator of Deck Beasts or the other demos made with some AI, I played your demo and really enjoyed it! I just think it illustrates my example well.

document fetched 2026-10-24 10:28 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1xdm41k/new_dev_next_fest_and_ai_ramblings