the whole Jensen being a 'traitor' for selling chips to China narrative doesn't actually make sense...
retained text
I keep seeing people call Huang a traitor over Nvidia chips going to China but there is something that's not adding up,.. and correct me if im wrong of course.. Nvidia can’t ship these chips without export licences from the US government, fair enough. Huang can lobby all he wants (and he does) but the actual yes or no comes from Washington. Here’s what Washington did: * **April 2025:** The Trump administration ***banned H20 exports to China. Then a few months later it reversed it.*** * **August 2025:** Trump asked Huang for 20% of Nvidia’s China H20 revenue to be paid to the government, they ended up settling on 15%. AMD got the same deal for it’s MI308. Trump’s own words at the press conference: “We negotiated a little deal.” * **December 2025:** Trump posted on Truth Social that Nvidia could ship **H200s** to “approved customers in China”, said he told Xi and “President Xi responded positively!”, and that 25% would be paid to the US. According to the Institute for Progress the H200 is nearly 6x more powerful then the H20. So it went from too dangerous to sell, to fine for 15%, to a much better chip being fine for 25%. Every one of those terms was **set by the president himself, not by Nvidia.** And it’s not only Democrats who think this is strange: * Derek Scissors from the conservative American Enterprise Institute said “There’s no precedent for this, probably because export taxes are unconstitutional.” The Constitution does actually ban taxes on exports (Article I, Section 9). * Republican Rep. John Moolenaar said China would “rip off” Nvidia’s technology. * Elizabeth Warren said H200 sales would “turbocharge China’s military.” * Several former export control officials have asked what legal authority the administration even has to do this. Then there’s the UAE, which is even wilder tbh... The WSJ reported that days before the inauguration, a vehicle backed by Sheikh Tahnoon (the UAE’s national security adviser) bought 49% of the Trump family’s crypto company World Liberty Financial for $500M, with $187M going to Trump family entities. A few months later the US agreed to let the UAE import around **500,000 advanced chips a year, with 100,000 a year** earmarked for G42, which is Tahnoon’s own AI company and was previously restricted because of it’s ties to China. The White House says their is no connection... but??? To be fair, Huang did lobby hard for China access and you can absolutely criticise him for that. But asking for a licence isn’t treason. Granting the licence and taking a cut of every sale is a government decision. **If selling chips to China is betraying the country, then the people who approved it and got paid for it should be first in line, not the CEO.** Sources, sinceyou'll all call it ai anyway * [15% deal](https://exportcompliancedaily.com/article/2025/08/12/us-cut-of-chip-export-revenue-to-china-raises-legal-questions-former-officials-say-2508110044) * [H200 reversal](https://www.theregister.com/2025/12/09/trump_gpu_export_ban_reversal) * [25% fee / 6x / critics](https://www.arise.tv/us-approves-nvidias-h200-ai-chip-exports-to-china-imposes-25-fee/) * [AEI quote (AP)](https://www.daytondailynews.com/news/nation-world/nvidia-and-amd-to-pay-15-of-china-chip-sale-revenue-to-us-government-in-an-unusual-agreement/YJONLOZHF5PQ3PM6SU4QRJRAOI) * [UAE stake (WSJ via The Block)](https://www.theblock.co/post/387931) * [G42 allocation](https://www.americanprogress.org/?p=149181)
document fetched 2026-11-14 00:35 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/wallstreetbets/comments/1xvfp61/the_whole_jensen_being_a_traitor_for_selling