← sources

Technically great employee, but chronically late

source: reddit (reddit:IndianWorkplace)published 2026-10-03 02:43ingested 2026-10-04 02:39

retained text

I work in a consultancy on major projects, with teams embedded in the client’s office. Physical presence is part of the job — WFH isn’t an option and everyone in my industry knows it.

On a multi-billion-dollar project, we hired someone in their late 20s for a specialist skill set. Technically, they’re excellent and fit in well with the team.

The problem started after probation.

We work 5 days a week, 8am–6pm with an hour break. I’m not strict about 8:00 sharp; by 8:30 everyone, including the client, is normally in. This person regularly arrives at 8.45 - 9.15 and still leaves on time.

Their manager has spoken to them, their skip-level has spoken to them, HR has issued a an email, and the client has noticed. Every time it’s raised, the answer is basically: “It’s too difficult to get up that early.”

I also know the commute is around 20 minutes because they live down the street from me.

I don’t like firing people, especially when their work is genuinely very good. But it’s becoming unfair to everyone else who manages to turn up on time every day.

At this point, they seem to believe 8:00am is more of a suggestion than a start time.

What would you do?

TL;DR: Excellent specialist on a multi-billion-dollar project. Fine during probation, now routinely arrives 9–9:30, leaves on time, and says getting up early is too difficult. Management, HR and the client are all aware. Great work, terrible punctuality. What next?

document fetched 2026-10-04 00:39 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/IndianWorkplace/comments/1wwc71y/technically_great_employee_but_chronically_late