Let it burn, or AI slop is killing games and that's good
retained text
I gave a bit of thought to the current "slop situation" in our industry. Got no objective conclusions, but some personal ones. Here's what it looks like from my POV: 1. Slop isn't a new phenomenon. We saw slop 5 years ago, 10 years ago; I assume we saw it 40-50 years ago. Just in a smaller amount. Current AI slop is just the next stage on a long path, most likely not the last. 2. I've never considered clones as good games; the same is true for "popular game + a single USP" games. They may be good products, especially in mobile gamedev where you burn money into A/B tests and unit economy to win percentages of conversion. But as games, in my opinion, they are bad. I don't want to play a pure clone of Dwarf Fortress, or a "RimWorld + a single USP" or reskinned Civilization, whatever — they are not fun for me. 3. What I want is to ingest new ideas, new experiences. It may be totally new things or conceptual rethinking of existing ones, but new. Novelty is important. 4. I also like ingesting polished experiences of original genre-defining games. You know, ones that have become a source for cloning after release. But the slop problem doesn't affect them, so we could keep them out of the discussion. 5. I.e., I don't understand why I should play games that are worse than the original ones. 6. Do we see a spam of conceptually new slop games? No. We see a spam of cheap clones. 7. => We don't have more good games; we have more bad games. Is it a problem? No, I don't want to play bad games; why should I care how many of them are released? 8. => We should let them kill each other; let's them burn :-D You may tell some buts: "But conceptually new games will be lost in the slop!" — No, they won't. Word of mouth still works; novel games may have a slower start, but they'll be all right. "But my game is really GOOD, and I'm affected!" — Be honest with yourself. If your game is affected by the current AI slop, your game is-not-so-good-as-you-think. There may be multiple reasons for that, and it definitely could be improved, but before that you should be honest and admit that your game is not a genre-defining one, not a conceptually new one, not a polished one — it is just one of the many not-so-good games. "I'm learning to make good games, but how will I learn if no one will play my game?" — You'll learn by doing; you'll learn by getting feedback from your friends, your colleagues, a few players. You don't need to have a big audience to get feedback. "But I need to earn money to live!" — Are you sure that making mediocre games (1) was your original aspiration? (2) is a good way to spend your life and earn money? I hope the answers to both questions are "no". "But making games is my hobby; I want to share it with people!" — Share it; there is no problem with sharing your hobby. Just remember that not only you have such a hobby, but many others have it too — they also want to share — there is no reason why the results of your hobby should be more shareable than the results of others' hobbies. "But someone should risk creating novelty!" — Yes, novelty does not guarantee success — creating it is a huge risk. Be responsible and honest. If you took a risk, don't whine if it didn't pay off — be proud of it. If you didn't take a risk, don't whine about being afraid to take one. It is life, and it is hard and unfair, but we're intellectual beings — we could and should calculate risks, and we should boldly face the consequences of our actions.
document fetched 2026-10-28 00:26 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1xgolvj/let_it_burn_or_ai_slop_is_killing_games_and_thats