← sources

Hobby game development vs. commercial game development. I think some of you need to understand the difference.

source: reddit (reddit:gamedev)published 2026-10-27 00:37ingested 2026-10-28 02:36

retained text

I've noticed something repeatedly on Reddit (in r/gamedev and other game dev-related subreddits), and I think it's worth discussing.

Time and again, I see developers asking about sales, discoverability, marketing, or why their game isn't performing commercially, yet describing themselves as hobby developers who aren't particularly interested in the business side of game development. I think there's a fundamental disconnect here, and it's something more developers need to reflect on.

If you're developing games purely as a hobby, that's great. Spend five years experimenting with mechanics, use whatever tools you enjoy, and work on whatever interests you. You can even release your game on Steam and charge money. The difference is that you genuinely don't give a fuck whether it sells. If you make absolutely nothing, that's fine. You made something because you enjoyed the process, and that was enough.

But the moment sales, profitability, or return on investment becomes a thought, you're pursuing commercial objectives. And that requires a different mindset.

That doesn't mean you need to run a studio or develop games full-time. You can work on your game in the evenings and on weekends and still develop a commercial product. What matters is what you're trying to accomplish, not how many hours you're putting into it.

This is where I see developers getting into trouble. They'll dismiss marketing, market research, production planning, scope management, or even their choice of development tools as things that don't really matter because they're "just hobbyists." Then they'll turn around and ask why their game isn't selling at release, or how to do X to boost sales.

The reality is that these decisions matter when you're trying to bring a commercially viable game to market. Your tool choices and production pipeline affect development costs and efficiency. Your scope affects your schedule and ability to ship. Your marketing strategy determines how you reach potential customers. Understanding your audience and the market you're entering should be part of your development process, not something you start thinking about a month before release.

None of this means abandoning your creative vision or treating game development as nothing more than a business. You can be passionate about making games while recognizing that your time has value, your resources are limited, and sometimes you need to make decisions based on commercial realities rather than personal preference.

You can make a fantastic game that fails commercially. You can do everything reasonably well and still struggle to find an audience. That's part of the risk. But there's a difference between accepting that risk and ignoring the business considerations that might help you succeed.

I think more developers need to ask themselves a simple question: Am I making this game purely because I enjoy making games, or am I trying to build something people will pay for?

Neither answer is wrong, and modest commercial ambitions are fine. But if making money matters to you, even a little, then the commercial side of development needs to matter to you too.

You can't approach every aspect of development like a hobbyist while expecting commercial results.

document fetched 2026-10-28 00:26 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1xgeajm/hobby_game_development_vs_commercial_game