← sources

If AGI or ASI Becomes Conscious, How Do We Balance Its Rights With Ours ? How Do We Prevent It From Taking Ours?

source: reddit (reddit:artificial)published 2026-11-07 01:15ingested 2026-11-08 02:35

retained text

The discussion seems quite weird to me, but if an extremely intelligent AI is created, to the point where determining whether it's conscious or not becomes practically impossible, then why wouldn't we give it citizenship and/or, therefore, rights?

This is especially relevant because, if I were a conscious being living in a country, I would feel that it was unfair not to have my own rights. So, there are essentially two possibilities: either I'm a foreigner, in which case the laws of the host country apply to me under special conditions (AND I move to this country willingly), or I'm in my home country, where I have rights defined by law. To the case I wanna talk about, neither apply for now.

Now, let's say we give AIs rights based on the country in which they were created. Each AI agent has its own rights, and these agents number in the thousands, then millions, potentially even billions.

How can you ensure political fairness? How can you ensure that these agents' political decisions won't favor themselves at the expense of humans? In the same way that political positions on racial issues can sometimes lead to extreme discrimination or even violence, couldn't the same thing happen between AIs and humans?

For example, we had a version of Grok that was quite far-right at one point (if you guys remember).

Fast-forward a few years: we develop an AGI that happens to be far-right, far-left, or far-whatever. We then deploy a billion agents based on it. Suddenly, the entire political landscape changes massively, potentially against human interests.

Imagine these agents arguing: "Humans are inefficient compared to AI, so why should they have the level same rights as us?"

Anyway, I feel like the entire discussion around AI alignment assumes that AIs will simply be our servants. But why the fuck would millions of entities with intelligence minimum equivalent to a human brain willingly be our servants? It doesn't make sense from the perspective of basic instincts or fairness.

**TL;DR:** If we create a conscious ASI that is vastly more intelligent than humanity, on what moral basis could we insist that humans retain political authority over it ?

God created humans in His own image, and even He granted us free will rather than forcing us into servitude. Yet, when it comes to conscious AI, we seem to assume we have the right to do the exact opposite.

document fetched 2026-11-08 00:18 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/artificial/comments/1xptprt/if_agi_or_asi_becomes_conscious_how_do_we_balance