Why "AI can do 80% of your job" is such a big fallacy
retained text
An often heard quote from the AI crowd, and even people who are not necessarily pro AI, is that "it can do 80% of your job", inadvertently implying that we are nearly useless, and soon to be made totally useless "once it gets better". I wanted to make a quick post about this and why it is so misleading. 1. If you were only able to do 80% of your job you would not get 80% of your salary. Instead, you would just not get hired. No employer is going to pay 2 people to do the same job, 1 person for the 80% and the other for the remaining 20%. It is also not true that 1 AI-enabled employee is necessarily better than 2 AI-free employees for various reasons, but that's an entirely different story. 2. There is no sign that it will be ever more than 80% since LLMs have logarithmic growth and we are already on the right hand side of the curve. Honestly, how much have LLMs improved over the last 6 months since Opus 4.6? I personally haven't noticed any major changes since that time. Indeed, many in the pro crowd will say that it has gotten worse not better. This is not even accounting for the relative increase in token usage, a sneaky way to increase the price. One thing is for sure, it has gotten more expensive, but has it gotten better? 3. The most important part: It is not 80%. AI can do exactly 0% of your job, since it is not sentient and thus needs a human to do anything at all. Even Agentic AI (which doesn't exist for the same reason) needs a human to start off the chain, monitor it, and review the result as well. You can wrap as many layers as you want around the chatbot, it is still you prompting it, and you engineering the harnesses, essentially front loading the work. Even if we take the premise at face-value, an AI still doesn't have a clue what its doing. It's just making probability calculations based on previous data. Both the probability part and the previous data part can be completely wrong and it will have no idea why. In fact, it wont even ask the 'why'. At best it will ask a human for intervention, at worst it will just carry on making things worse. We programmers are not making coffee mugs, but rather incredibly complex and often poorly-specified software. AI just throws a bunch of slop at it until eventually something sticks. It's brute-forcing of a problem, which is just as inefficient as it sounds, and a terrible idea in engineering in general. So saying AI can do 80% of your job is like saying a chef's knife can do 80% of a chef's job; correct at face-value, but an insanely retarded statement if you really think about it. To be clear, I think this counts not just for SWE but basically any profession. Many people will say that CEO's don't care and will still try to replace you anyway. Trust me, I know. My company fired 50% in about a year time under the guise of AI. The real reason was that we were simply going to run out of money soon, but that doesn't look good when you are trying to please investors. ^(This post is 100% AI-free 🌿)
document fetched 2026-09-07 00:22 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/cscareerquestions/comments/1w8zyec/why_ai_can_do_80_of_your_job_is_such_a_big_fallacy