← sources

Lost a Chargeback Dispute... What's Next?

source: reddit (reddit:shopify)published 2026-09-26 17:59ingested 2026-09-27 02:38

retained text

We sell T-shirts, so we're not talking high-dollar sales here. Still, after thousands of successful transactions, I had a customer initiate a chargeback instead of simply requesting a return. Despite overwhelming evidence that he is lying about the case and is blatantly committing fraud, his bank sided with him (shocker, I know), so he now has our product, took his payment back, and we incurred a $15 chargeback fee. This isn't about the actual chargeback case of which there are plenty to choose from here on Reddit, but what's next, as I hate liars and thieves and don't just want to let him walk away. 

With that said, has anyone reached out to a chargeback customer to recover your merchandise and actually managed to get it back? If so, have an example of your messages to them? Do I reach out to let them know that by keeping our product, they are committing fraud? That they have a balance due? That we are reporting them to multiple agencies and sending them to collections? Are there even collection agencies that take low-dollar accounts? I'm only out like $57 and have already written the money off, so I don't care how big of a cut they get, as this is just on principle at this point. 



document fetched 2026-09-27 00:30 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/shopify/comments/1wqx28z/lost_a_chargeback_dispute_whats_next