← sources

Grok Bot vs. Muse: who actually wins? 20+ hours with each personal AI agent.

source: reddit (reddit:AI_Agents)published 2026-10-13 19:49ingested 2026-10-14 02:36

retained text

This comparison comes from 20-plus hours with each personal AI agent over one week of running a solopreneur business, first on one and then the other. The business runs on Muse now. The numbers below come from the account's own usage.

**TL;DR**

- **Price:** Muse wins clearly. Free includes 100M tokens a week. $16 a month buys 500M plus Meta's new Wonder model.
- **Smarts:** Grok Bot wins for now. It handles more work on its own. It also costs far more to run. This week's usage needed the $200 plan. Usage on X's new $30 unified plan may work out differently.
- **Setup:** A tie when properly set up. With instructions and jobs in files you own, both agents run the same bots and the same jobs. That is what made switching possible.

**Setup is the same on both.** Grok Bot ran six bots: a chief of staff, a builder, a writing and social bot, relationships, research and a personal coach. In Muse each one became its own chat. Every bot or chat has a job description, shared rules for how to communicate and its own personality. All of it lives in one repository that both agents can read.

**Some bots work better as skills.** The research bot followed the same procedure every time, so it became a skill that any bot can run. The relationships bot ended up calling the relationships skill for everything, because the contact records already live in a folder that works as a CRM.

**Why separate bots at all?** Parallel work is not the reason, since all of these tools can hand a task to subagents. The reasons that hold up are about people and control. Different conversations call for different roles, and a personal coach covers different ground from a chief of staff. A separate bot keeps its context focused, along with its own personality, preferences and memory. Each bot also has its own schedule, spending and permissions, so it is clear which one ran a job and what it cost.

**Price: Muse, easily.** Muse's plans on October 13:

| Plan | Price | Tokens per week |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Free | $0 | 100M |
| Power | $16/month on the web, $20 in the iPhone app | 500M |
| Maximum | $80/month | 3B |

Actual usage runs a couple hundred million tokens a week. The account also started with about 3B bonus tokens, so cost was never a concern. It moved to Power on October 13 anyway, to get Wonder.

Grok Bot went very differently:

| Date | Plan | What happened |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Oct 4 | Free | Ran out during a Sunday workshop |
| Oct 4 | $20/month | Gone in about a day. About half went to one job that checks email every 5 to 10 minutes |
| Oct 7 | $60/month | Moved up |
| Oct 9 | $200/month | Moved up again |
| Oct 12 | $30, X's unified plan | Switched to the new bundle and the $200 plan was refunded |

**Why Grok Bot costs so much.** Three things multiply each other.

- **Frequency.** Scheduled jobs run all day. The email job runs every 5 to 10 minutes and used about half of the $20 plan by itself.
- **Context.** Every run re-reads its rules, its job file and the records it needs. On the chief of staff bot's bigger jobs, 85 to 97% of the tokens were re-read context.
- **Length.** Runs of more than 15 steps produced 52% of the week's usage cost.

Claude Code also uses a lot of Opus tokens. Its usage limits are generous enough that it does not matter there. The same email job uses a lot of tokens on Muse too. Muse's allowance is generous enough that it does not matter.

**Smarts: Grok Bot, for now.** Grok Bot is smarter. With Muse's Spark models, all writing, real planning and judgment went to Claude. Grok Bot handles more of that itself. Where exactly it wins is harder to pin down, because the week was daily use with no side-by-side test of the same tasks. On October 7, Elon Musk announced that Grok Bot will use the best back-end model for each task, including Claude Opus 5.5. The usage page shows separate allowances for Grok models and other models.

**Muse Wonder is the wild card.** Theo Browne ranks it next to Opus 5.5 and pairs the two for coding in his own tool, T3 Code. He says the subscriber-only "Full" version is the good one and calls the standard version "significantly worse." After the upgrade, Muse reported that it switched from Spark to Wonder. It did not say which version.

**The files matter more than either agent.** One AGENTS.md holds shared rules and a routing table that points to each folder. Each folder has a CONTEXT.md map. Each bot has a job description file, and each recurring job is a file too. The scheduled task in either agent is one sentence that names the job file, plus a few host settings. Run records go back into the repo. After the switch, the new agent saw every job and every past run.

**Where the heavy work goes.** Personal agents handle conversations with a role and jobs on a schedule. Detailed, interactive building belongs in Claude or Codex, whether it is knowledge work or code. Claude Projects organizes several sessions and keeps them coordinated. Codex does something similar through tasks, or through one session that manages others. Both can fan a task out to many subagents.

**It is still not seamless.** Chat histories did not move until each bot was asked to export its own. Grok Bot had not updated the file for the morning job that scans X and prompts for a dictation. Facebook, Instagram and X connections have to be set up again on each platform.

**Which one to pick.**

| If you | Pick |
| --- | --- |
| Are just starting out | Muse, free plan |
| Run a lot of scheduled jobs | Muse Power at $16, with writing sent to Claude |
| Need a smarter agent and will watch usage | Grok Bot at $30 |

A Wonder test is under way now. Muse writes a plan and also asks Claude for one, so the two can be compared and Wonder's limits found. Results will follow in a later post.

document fetched 2026-10-14 00:19 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/AI_Agents/comments/1x56s72/grok_bot_vs_muse_who_actually_wins_20_hours_with