Your AI agent completed the task. Someone else paid the price.
retained text
A support agent moves the easy tickets to the front of the queue. Response times improve. The dashboard looks better. Meanwhile, a customer locked out of the account they need to run payroll is still waiting. Would we call that agent successful? I’ve been thinking about this because so much of how we evaluate agents comes back to whether they did what we asked. That matters, obviously. But in this example, the instruction itself leaves something out. We asked for faster support without saying much about whose wait matters most, or how much worse we’re willing to make it for people with difficult problems. The agent doesn’t need to invent a malicious plan. Depending on how the queue and incentives work, prioritizing easy tickets might be a perfectly reasonable way to improve the number we gave it. People do this too. Anyone who has worked against a badly chosen target will recognize the temptation. I wouldn’t argue that a human would necessarily catch the problem or care more. What worries me about agents is how easily that choice can become routine. A queue gets reordered all day, every day, and eventually a prioritization decision nobody discussed is just how support works. And the person waiting probably has no idea. They can’t see the metric. They don’t know that their complicated problem keeps losing to five simpler ones. There are versions of this in pricing and scheduling too. A higher price might work because a customer has nowhere else to go. A more efficient staff schedule might leave someone unable to arrange childcare. Some of those tradeoffs may be defensible. But I’d want someone to have considered them before treating the result as an improvement. That’s the part I’m unsure we’re capturing. We can record the request, the tool calls, and the outcome. But how do we even notice that an outcome celebrated as a success for one party has quietly imposed a cost on somebody else? If you’re deploying agents, I’d be interested in what you actually do here. Do you track effects on people outside the request? Have you ever changed an agent’s behavior because its success metrics were hiding a problem like this?
document fetched 2026-10-25 00:19 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/AI_Agents/comments/1xdv92i/your_ai_agent_completed_the_task_someone_else