← sources

Vibe Coding

source: reddit (reddit:ClaudeAI)published 2026-10-28 05:49ingested 2026-10-29 02:37

retained text

I see a lot of people dismiss AI's potential to replace software engineers because of the amount of "slop" it produces, particularly when non technical people are vibe coding.

For context, I'm a SWE myself. I'm not saying AI replacing us is inevitable, but I find it strange how confidently some developers dismiss the possibility based on the quality of today's vibe coded apps

And I get the criticism. Someone with little to no engineering experience can ask AI to build an application, and the result might be one giant spaghetti code monolith with terrible architecture, questionable security, and zero maintainability.

But why does that automatically mean AI can't eventually replace software engineers?

It's not like traditional software development started with perfectly architected applications.

Look at Twitter. Its early infrastructure struggled to keep up with its growth, to the point where the infamous "Fail Whale" became synonymous with its reliability problems. But Twitter evolved, its infrastructure matured, and its engineering practices adapted.

The software industry is full of successful companies that started with simple architectures, accumulated technical debt, and eventually had to refactor or rebuild entire systems.

We don't judge the long term capabilities of human software engineers by the shortcomings of their earliest implementations. So why do we use poorly vibe coded applications to establish the limits of AI?

A person with no engineering experience prompting AI to build an application isn't necessarily going to produce something well engineered. But that doesn't mean AI is fundamentally incapable of producing better software.

I'm not saying AI will replace software engineers. (Okay, maybe I am a little hahah). I'm saying that pointing to spaghetti code as proof that it never could is a weak argument.

**Bad code is evidence of bad code** It isn't proof of a permanent technological ceiling.

document fetched 2026-10-29 00:23 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/ClaudeAI/comments/1xhfytz/vibe_coding