A democracy that answers: why nothing moves in India until someone makes a call, and what I think would change it
extract
I've been thinking about this for a long time and finally wrote it down. It's long. I'm one person, not an organisation, and not connected to any party. Tell me where it's wrong. I didn't write this because of one bad experience. I wrote it because I'm tired of watching how much this country could be, and how much of it gets wasted, by every party and every office, not just one. And of how used to it we've all become. **Short version:** officials ignore you because it costs them nothing. This is about how to make it cost something, and what I want to build. The formatted version is here: https://jaago.pages.dev/?src=reddit-india * * * > "Kisi ko jaante ho?" Do you know someone? When something goes wrong with the government in India, that is the first question anyone asks. Nobody asks what the rule is. Your father's pension stops. The land record has the wrong name on it. The hospital says there is no bed. The transformer has been dead for a week. In each case there is a rule that says what should happen, and an officer whom our taxes pay to make it happen. And in each case the family sits down and makes a list of people they know. A cousin in the department. A friend's uncle who is close to the corporator or the sarpanch. Somebody who can make a call. We do this so automatically that we've stopped noticing how strange it is. The rule is written down. The officer is paid. But what moves the file is a phone call from someone who matters. If you don't know someone, you learn the other vocabulary. Kal aana. Sahab seat par nahi hain. Ho jayega. You stand at a counter and wait for someone to look up. You say "sir" to a person whose salary you pay. You fold your hands for something that was already yours. And if it's urgent, you find the agent who sits outside the gate, and you pay. It isn't a fee. It's a ransom for your own right. It's worth asking why the phone call works. Watch what happens when the MLA's assistant calls. The officer who was not in the seat is in it. The file that could not be found is found. Nobody became a better person in ten minutes. What changed is that ignoring this caller would cost something: a transfer, a word to the boss, trouble. Ignoring you costs nothing. That is the whole problem. There is exactly one time when it costs something, and you already know when. Notice when the road gets tarred, when the water tanker turns up, when the leader comes to your door. It is the month before an election. For those few weeks, you are expensive to ignore. Then you vote, and the price of ignoring you falls back to zero for five years. An officer in a government office does arithmetic all day. There are more files than hours. Some files have someone behind them and some have no one. The ones with someone behind them get done. The ones with no one wait, and one of those is a widow's pension. And it isn't only delay. A road is billed twice and built once, and we pay both bills. Medicines are bought on paper. A teacher is paid and never comes. The ration is weighed short. That is our money, and somebody is taking it. They don't hide very hard, because they don't have to. The people they take it from are alone. Everyone knows this. There is nobody in India who doesn't. Ask anyone why their work didn't get done and they'll tell you: no approach, no source, nobody behind me. What keeps it alive is that we have accepted it. Yahan aisa hi hota hai. Kuch nahi badlega. That shrug is the most dependable thing the system has. So we keep being handed new ways to complain: a portal, a helpline, an app, a grievance cell. Each one is a new door into the same room. A complaint with nobody behind it is a file with nobody behind it. That's why yours comes back marked "closed" while the problem sits exactly where it was. The real question isn't how to complain. It's how to become expensive to ignore. There have only ever been two ways. One is to be important, or to know someone who is. The other is to unite, and to stay united. The people who take your money already know this. The contractor, the officer who signs for the contractor, and the leader who protects them both have never once acted alone. They are organized. We are not. That is the whole difference between us, and it is the one thing we can change. We saw this year what happens when we do. In May, students came out over a leaked national exam. Ten weeks later a Union minister had resigned. A protest takes the cost of ignoring people from zero to unbearable, almost overnight. But a protest is a spike. People have jobs and exams and children, so they go home, and the cost falls back to zero. Within a month of that resignation, the same students were planning another march, because what they had been promised had not been done. They won a promise. Nobody was left to collect it. And you can't hold a protest about a pothole. Most of what wears you down is small: the drain, the water that comes for one hour, the dead streetlight, the certificate, the bill that is wrong every month. Nobody will fill a maidan for these. So the cost of ignoring them stays at zero forever, and they are most of your life. What we need is a way to stay united without living on the street. Here is what that looks like. The road outside your house was relaid last winter. By July it is craters. You complain. Ho jayega. Your neighbour complains. Ho jayega. Each of you, alone, is a file with nobody behind it. Now suppose you could see what the office sees. The first thing you'd learn is that you are not alone: forty other roads in your city broke in the same monsoon, and on every one of them people are asking your question. The second thing is in the records. Eleven of those roads were built by the same firm. It was paid for each one, with our money. On each, the same engineer signed that the work was satisfactory. And under the contract, the firm must repair every one of them at its own cost for a year or more after building it. Nobody told you that. Why would they? So forty lanes stop being forty complaints. They become one demand, on the desk of the one officer who can order the repair, with everything attached: the contracts, the payments, the certificates, and the names. These eleven roads, rebuilt by this firm at its own cost, by this date. And below that, what follows if the date passes: the officer's superior, the auditor, the court and the newspapers, in that order, with the same papers. Look at it from that officer's chair. This file has four thousand families behind it, and they have found each other. The papers cannot be lost, because everyone has them. The officer's own name is on a deadline the whole city can see. For the first time, protecting the firm is more dangerous than making it work. The crews come out that week. They work at night. And the people who were told ho jayega for a year stand at their gates and watch the road being laid properly, by the firm our taxes had already paid once. Nobody shouted. Nobody begged. Nobody paid. That is one city and one department. A broken scheme, an exam or a pension takes people across many districts. A national question takes lakhs, and lawyers, and patience. Whether a voter list was changed fairly is one of those, and today no citizen can check that for themselves. The higher you go, the harder they push back, and the more of us it takes. But it is the same thing every time: people who have found each other, a record with names and dates, and no intention of going home. So the people we elect are checked once in five years, and the people we pay are never checked at all. We need a check that runs every day, at every level, and is run by the people affected. It doesn't exist yet because organizing is tedious. Finding the others who share your problem, agreeing on one demand, digging out the records, remembering six months later who promised what: people with full lives can't do it. But tedious, exact, never-forgetting work is what software is for, and we've used it for everything else. In fifteen years India built public systems for identity, for payments, for tax. Those systems did not make anyone more honest. They made it impossible to say the money never came. Nothing like that exists for a promise, a deadline or a file. A citizen asking the state a question still runs on "kisi ko jaante ho?" So we're building it: a free, open tool that does the tedious part. It finds the other people with your problem. It helps you settle on one demand and find the one officer who can sign it. It keeps the record: what was asked, of whom, by what date, and what they said. It remembers the date so nobody has to. It joins twenty neighbourhoods into one demand. And it puts names on things, taken from the records and kept in front of everyone affected: the contractor, the engineer, the officer, and whoever sits above them. People behave differently when their neighbours can see what they signed. It is not another door for complaints. Offices are very good at drowning in complaints. The point is fewer demands, each with people behind it. I expect it to work for the same reason the phone call works. The MLA's assistant almost never has to call twice. Once an office knows that a group is expensive to ignore, the work gets done the first time. Most of the time nobody will have to escalate anything. The officer will see the people behind the file, see a name and a date on it, and do the arithmetic. Nobody will have become a better person. For once, the fear will run the other way. And on the day the file is ignored anyway, the people are already together, with the record in their hands. There is a small experiment from Delhi that shows it. People living in slums applied for ration cards. Most of those who simply applied and waited were still waiting a year later. Those who paid a bribe got their card. And those who did nothing except file a right-to-information request, asking what had happened to their application, got it almost as reliably as those who paid. They threatened no one. They showed that somebody was watching and would remember. Who is behind this? Right now, one person. Who am I? It doesn't matter, and it shouldn't. I'm an ordinary Indian, from Varanasi of all places. You have never heard of me, and that is the point: something like this must not depend on one person, and it must not belong to one. So it won't. Everything is public from the first day: the code, the rules, and every decision. Anyone can read it, and anyone can run their own copy, so nobody can quietly change what it does or switch it off. I am setting up a non-profit to hold it, and its rules will not let any one person or organization control it, me included. It will take no money from any political party. Every rupee it receives and every rupee it spends will be published. The tool will cost you nothing to use. It is cheap to run, and the non-profit will pay for that from small donations, published in full. It will run on servers spread across many hands, so that no single organization controls it, ours included. There is nothing in it for elections. And the officer who fixes the problem gets the credit, by name, whichever party runs the government. Honest officers exist. They should stop being the ones who lose. It isn't built yet, and I'd rather say so plainly. What exists is the design, the rules and the first pieces. I'm asking for two things. If you want this to exist, leave a way to reach you, and nothing else, so I can write to you when it is ready for your city. And if you can help build it, with code, law, design, translation, video, or just knowing your city, tell me what you can do. Both are here: https://jaago.pages.dev/?src=reddit-india I am not asking for money, and I am not asking for your vote. I am asking for one more thing, and it costs nothing. Send this to one person who has stood at that counter. For as long as anyone can remember, the answer to "kisi ko jaante ho?" has decided who gets water and who waits. The answer has always been a name. It should be: haan. Ek doosre ko. Yes. Each other. * * * If you think the argument is wrong, say where. I'd rather find out now.
retained text (truncated)
I've been thinking about this for a long time and finally wrote it down. It's long. I'm one person, not an organisation, and not connected to any party. Tell me where it's wrong. I didn't write this because of one bad experience. I wrote it because I'm tired of watching how much this country could be, and how much of it gets wasted, by every party and every office, not just one. And of how used to it we've all become. **Short version:** officials ignore you because it costs them nothing. This is about how to make it cost something, and what I want to build. The formatted version is here: https://jaago.pages.dev/?src=reddit-india * * * > "Kisi ko jaante ho?" Do you know someone? When something goes wrong with the government in India, that is the first question anyone asks. Nobody asks what the rule is. Your father's pension stops. The land record has the wrong name on it. The hospital says there is no bed. The transformer has been dead for a week. In each case there is a rule that says what should happen, and an officer whom our taxes pay to make it happen. And in each case the family sits down and makes a list of people they know. A cousin in the department. A friend's uncle who is close to the corporator or the sarpanch. Somebody who can make a call. We do this so automatically that we've stopped noticing how strange it is. The rule is written down. The officer is paid. But what moves the file is a phone call from someone who matters. If you don't know someone, you learn the other vocabulary. Kal aana. Sahab seat par nahi hain. Ho jayega. You stand at a counter and wait for someone to look up. You say "sir" to a person whose salary you pay. You fold your hands for something that was already yours. And if it's urgent, you find the agent who sits outside the gate, and you pay. It isn't a fee. It's a ransom for your own right. It's worth asking why the phone call works. Watch what happens when the MLA's assistant calls. The officer who was not in the seat is in it. The file that could not be found is found. Nobody became a better person in ten minutes. What changed is that ignoring this caller would cost something: a transfer, a word to the boss, trouble. Ignoring you costs nothing. That is the whole problem. There is exactly one time when it costs something, and you already know when. Notice when the road gets tarred, when the water tanker turns up, when the leader comes to your door. It is the month before an election. For those few weeks, you are expensive to ignore. Then you vote, and the price of ignoring you falls back to zero for five years. An officer in a government office does arithmetic all day. There are more files than hours. Some files have someone behind them and some have no one. The ones with someone behind them get done. The ones with no one wait, and one of those is a widow's pension. And it isn't only delay. A road is billed twice and built once, and we pay both bills. Medicines are bought on paper. A teacher is paid and never comes. The ration is weighed short. That is our money, and somebody is taking it. They don't hide very hard, because they don't have to. The people they take it from are alone. Everyone knows this. There is nobody in India who doesn't. Ask anyone why their work didn't get done and they'll tell you: no approach, no source, nobody behind me. What keeps it alive is that we have accepted it. Yahan aisa hi hota hai. Kuch nahi badlega. That shrug is the most dependable thing the system has. So we keep being handed new ways to complain: a portal, a helpline, an app, a grievance cell. Each one is a new door into the same room. A complaint with nobody behind it is a file with nobody behind it. That's why yours comes back marked "closed" while the problem sits exactly where it was. The real question isn't how to complain. It's how to become expensive to ignore. There have only ever been two ways. One is to be important, or to know someone who is. The other is to unite, and to stay united. The people who take your money already know this. The contractor, the officer who signs for the contractor, and the leader who protects them both have never once acted alone. They are organized. We are not. That is the whole difference between us, and it is the one thing we can change. We saw this year what happens when we do. In May, students came out over a leaked national exam. Ten weeks later a Union minister had resigned. A protest takes the cost of ignoring people from zero to unbearable, almost overnight. But a protest is a spike. People have jobs and exams and children, so they go home, and the cost falls back to zero. Within a month of that resignation, the same students were planning another march, because what they had been promised had not been done. They won a promise. Nobody was left to collect it. And you can't hold a protest about a pothole. Most of what wears you down is small: the drain, the water that comes for one hour, the dead streetlight, the certificate, the bill that is wrong every month. Nobody will fill a maidan for these. So the cost of ignoring them stays at zero forever, and they are most of your life. What we need is a way to stay united without living on the street. Here is what that looks like. The road outside your house was relaid last winter. By July it is craters. You complain. Ho jayega. Your neighbour complains. Ho jayega. Each of you, alone, is a file with nobody behind it. Now suppose you could see what the office sees. The first thing you'd learn is that you are not alone: forty other roads in your city broke in the same monsoon, and on every one of them people are asking your question. The second thing is in the records. Eleven of those roads were built by the same firm. It was paid for each one, with our money. On each, the same engineer signed that the work was satisfactory. And under the contract, the firm must repair every one of them at its own cost for a year or more after building it. Nobody told you that. Why would they? So forty lanes stop being forty complaints. They become one demand, on the desk of the one officer who can order the repair, with everything attached: the contracts, the payments, the certificates, and the names. These eleven roads, rebuilt by this firm at its own cost, by this date. And below that, what follows if the date passes: the officer's superior, the auditor, the court and the newspapers, in that order, with the same papers. Look at it from that officer's chair. This file has four thousand families behind it, and they have found each other. The papers cannot be lost, because everyone has them. The officer's own name is on a deadline the whole city can see. For the first time, protecting the firm is more dangerous than making it work. The crews come out that week. They work at night. And the people who were told ho jayega for a year stand at their gates and watch the road being laid properly, by the firm our taxes had already paid once. Nobody shouted. Nobody begged. Nobody paid. That is one city and one department. A broken scheme, an exam or a pension takes people across many districts. A national question takes lakhs, and lawyers, and patience. Whether a voter list was changed fairly is one of those, and today no citizen can check that for themselves. The higher you go, the harder they push back, and the more of us it takes. But it is the same thing every time: people who have found each other, a record with names and dates, and no intention of going home. So the people we elect are checked once in five years, and the people we pay are never checked at all. We need a check that runs every day, at every level, and is run by the people affected. It doesn't exist yet because organizing is tedious. Finding the others who share your problem, agreeing on one demand, digging out the records, remembering six months later who promised what: people with full lives can't do it. But tedious, exact, never-forgetting work is what software is for, and we've used it for everything else. In fifteen years India built public systems for identity, for payments, for tax. Those systems did not make anyone more honest. They made it impossible to say the money never came. Nothing like that exists for a promise, a deadline or a file. A citizen asking the state a question still runs on "kisi ko jaante ho?" So we're building it: a free, open tool that does the tedious part. It finds the other people with your problem. It helps you settle on one demand and find the one officer who can sign it. It keeps the record: what was asked, of whom, by what date, and what they said. It remembers the date so nobody has to. It joins twenty neighbourhoods into one demand. And it puts names on things, taken from the records and kept in front of everyone affected: the contractor, the engineer, the officer, and whoever sits above them. People behave differently when their neighbours can see what they signed. It is not another door for complaints. Offices are very good at drowning in complaints. The point is fewer demands, each with people behind it. I expect it to work for the same reason the phone call works. The MLA's assistant almost never has to call twice. Once an office knows that a group is expensive to ignore, the work gets done the first time. Most of the time nobody will have to escalate anything. The officer will see the people behind the file, see a name and a date on it, and do the arithmetic. Nobody will have become a better person. For once, the fear will run the other way. And on the day the file is ignored anyway, the people are already together, with the record in their hands. There is a small experiment from Delhi that shows it. People living in slums applied for ration cards. Most of those who simply applied and waited were still waiting a year later. Those who paid a bribe got their card. And those who did nothing except file a right-to-information request, asking what had happened to their application, got it almost as reliably as those who paid. They threatened no one. They showed that somebody was watching and would remember. Who is behind this? Right now, one person. Who am I? It doesn't matter, and it shouldn't. I'm an ordinary Indian, from Varanasi of all places. You have never heard of me, and that is the point: something like this must not depend on one person, and it must not belong to one. So it won't. Everything is public from the first day: the code, the rules, and every decision. Anyone can read it, and anyone can run their own copy, so nobody can quietly change what it does or switch it off. I am setting up a non-profit to hold it, and its rules will not let any one person or organization control it, me included. It will take no money from any political party. Every rupee it receives and every rupee it spends will be published. The tool will cost you nothing to use. It is cheap to run, and the non-profit will pay for that from small donations, published in full. It will run on servers spread across many hands, so that no single organization controls it, ours included. There is nothing in it for elections. And the officer who fixes the problem gets the credit, by name, whichever party runs the government. Honest officers exist. They should stop being the ones who lose. It isn't built yet, and I'd rather say so plainly. What exists is the design, the rules and the first pieces. I'm asking for two things. If you want this to exist, leave a way to reach you, and nothing else, so I can write to you when it is ready for your city. And if you can help build it, with code, law, design, translation, video, or just knowing your city, tell me what you can do. Both are here: https://jaago.pages.dev/?src=reddit-india I am not asking for money, and I am not asking for your vote. I am asking for one more thing, and it costs nothing. Send this to one person who has stood at that counter. For as long as anyone can remember, the answer to "kisi ko jaante ho?" has de
document fetched 2026-10-14 00:26 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/india/comments/1x4vj2q/a_democracy_that_answers_why_nothing_moves_in