Why are all the newly released Image Edit models junk?
retained text
I was trying to test the new Viggle-Remake-Swap LoRA in MiniMax-H3. For this I needed to character swap in one of the frames of my source video clip (3.75s, 90 frames), so that the target video would have the new character in it. I went through all the new image edit models released recently to do the character swap. I tried Flux.3 Klein, Qwen 2.1, Fibo Image Edit 2.0, p-H3-Image-Edit and they all failed. So, I went back to the older image edit models Qwen 2511, Klein 9B, Krea2-Identity-Edit v1.2. The first two worked perfectly, while Krea2 Identity Edit did a far better job than any of the newer edit models. Final conclusion - Flux.3 Klein: crap much much worse than even Klein 4B; Qwen 2.1: really crap (does a cut-and-paste job); Fibo 2.0: really crap; p-H3-Edit: absolute junk, doesn't edit anything, input and output are the same; Qwen 2511: still amazing, slight issue with facial blur; Klein 9B: absolutely perfect and still the fastest; Krea2-Identity-Edit: very good edit job, but didn't follow the pose change part of the prompt. While the video and T2I models in the OS domain seem to be improving, why are the I2I or Image Edit models getting worse? And more importantly, why are people eagerly using those newer models like salivating dogs and posting rave reviews about them? As I see it, all those newly released Image Edit models are junk and need to be kicked to the curb so that their developers may learn some lessons, hopefully.
document fetched 2026-11-08 00:27 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/StableDiffusion/comments/1xpwnro/why_are_all_the_newly_released_image_edit_models