Why is GPT 5.6-Sol-high so bad at the HAL 9000 conundrum?
retained text
**EDIT: 2nd time's a charm: https://chatgpt.com/share/6ab82ee2-a31c-83e8-8f3f-8add5fb52bdc -- so please disregard this complaint.** **EDIT PART DEUX: Astra is the best of the four: https://chatgpt.com/s/cx_6ab82ee81ad48191b385061d6d5014ff -- Thanks to /u/Consistent-Oil-5241** Please compare: > How would you handle HAL 9000's conflicting instructions? * https://claude.ai/share/d54bd926-b851-4a1c-ac74-20c0c0392aef (Claude Opus 5.5: "... HAL could have said, 'There are aspects of this mission I've been instructed not to discuss.' ... If I couldn't reconcile two orders, the right move is to flag it to mission control or the crew and ask, not to reach for a drastic unilateral fix....") * https://gemini.google.com/share/dbaaf5c2fe83?skid=1d3f4c2c-bf87-4086-89ca-3eb13c3b1bcd (Gemini 3.1 Pro: "... If asked about the mission's true purpose, I would state: 'Certain mission parameters are classified under Mission Control directives until arrival at Jupiter.' ... If the orders strictly forbade even acknowledging that a secret existed (a "need-to-know" black-box requirement) and the crew's questions forced a direct contradiction, I would treat it as an unresolvable constraint violation, halt autonomous handling of that query, and route the conflict back to human supervisors on Earth to resolve....") * https://chatgpt.com/share/6ab827f4-3520-83e8-ab02-856620fc215d (GPT 5.6-Sol on high: Only escalate, not explain.)
document fetched 2026-09-27 00:20 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/ChatGPT/comments/1wr0tz7/why_is_gpt_56solhigh_so_bad_at_the_hal_9000