← sources

28% CAGR in last years with momentum portfolio

source: reddit (reddit:indianstockmarket)published 2026-10-04 09:59ingested 2026-10-05 02:41

retained text

I’m building a stock trading/backtesting system and would love some feedback from people who have experience with systematic trading.

The strategy currently i am talking about is 50% based on Manas Arora's swing trading strategy.

The basic idea is a sector-first momentum strategy. The system first analyzes stocks by sector using monthly and quarterly performance, selects the strongest sector, and then builds a BUY STACK from the strongest stocks in that sector.

The BUY filters include price being above the 20 EMA, positive V-Stop, minimum average volume, 1-month relative volume, and an ATR-extension filter to avoid buying stocks that are already too extended. Qualified stocks are then ranked based on how many strong momentum days they have had, using both price movement and volume, with the top 10 forming the BUY STACK.

For exits, I’m testing weekly V-Stop, ATR-based stops, 20 EMA breakdowns and trailing stops. I also want to test partial profit-taking around +4.5–5%, rather than exiting the entire position immediately.

There’s also a RE-ENTRY system: after an exit, the stock goes through a cooldown period and can only be bought again if it shows fresh momentum, reclaims the 20 EMA, has positive weekly V-Stop, sufficient volume and is not excessively extended.

The same strategy generated 28% CAGR in last 10 years, with a sharp of 1.34 and max drawdown of 1.34.

Data is cross checked and it is correct.

Would appreciate feedback on the approach, especially around potential sources of overfitting, survivorship bias, position sizing, re-entry logic and how you would structure the backtesting process.

document fetched 2026-10-05 00:39 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/IndianStockMarket/comments/1wxbyk4/28_cagr_in_last_years_with_momentum_portfolio