← sources

Am I the AH for wanting product managers to actually validate ideas before I'm expected to design them?

source: reddit (reddit:ProductManagement)published 2026-09-12 17:13ingested 2026-09-13 02:38

retained text

I've been a UX designer for years, across several companies, and worked with a lot of different PMs. Now I'm at a large software company and I'm running into the same wall over and over: feature ideas show up already "validated" by vibes and gut instinct, not user demand. We‘ve had a lot of success in the past by being innovative and first to market in some untapped spaces. But now we’re turning into a feature factory without a lot of discipline that I can see - I might be missing a meeting or a memo but 80% of the things I work on, while they definitely seem fun and cool, they seem to be either playing catchup with competitors, or going off of someones cool idea, but not doublechecked with research as a clear market gap, opportunity, or life improvement.

UX could fill that gap by doing our own research and discovery, but in this engineering-first culture we’ve had to budget our time too tightly, and honestly there’s no clear expectation that we would do that work. Even bug/issue tickets get shoved down from the C-suite or spun up off a single customer support call, and we're supposed to just react. there’s no real signal on whether it's actually a widespread issue or a one-off. So priority ends up being decided by whoever's "taste" is loudest in the room, mine included.

I don't think these PMs are bad at their jobs. They're smart, they know their domain, they mean well. But I feel bad for even having this thought, like I'm secretly accusing them of not doing their homework when I think "we need to see evidence this is worth building."

Is wanting more data discipline before committing design/eng time a reasonable thing to push for, or is this just how it works at scale and I need to let it go? And if it IS worth pushing for, how do I actually start shifting that culture without coming off like I'm calling everyone's judgment into question (I have some major imposter syndrome)? How have others dealt with this challenge?

document fetched 2026-09-13 00:27 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/ProductManagement/comments/1wei7yv/am_i_the_ah_for_wanting_product_managers_to