← sources

The "safe" names are priced for 1.6 to 5.4 times their revenue growth.

source: reddit (reddit:ValueInvesting)published 2026-11-16 20:28ingested 2026-11-17 02:42

retained text

I wanted to know what growth today's prices actually assume for a few of the stocks people treat as safe. So I ran a plain reverse DCF on them and put the result next to what revenue actually did. Nvidia as comparison.

Setup, prices as of Nov 13, 2026:

* FCF = operating cash flow minus capex, trailing twelve months
* Solve for the annual FCF growth over 10 years that makes the discounted cash flows equal today's market cap. 9% discount rate, zero growth after year 10.
* Compare that with revenue growth over the last five fiscal years (six annual values, checked against the 10-Ks) and over the last twelve months

|Ticker|Required FCF growth p.a.|Revenue CAGR, last 5 FYs|Revenue growth, TTM|FCF margin TTM / 5-yr median|
|:-|:-|:-|:-|:-|
|WMT|26.8% (17.3% capex-normalized)|5.0%|6.2%|1.8% / 2.0%|
|COST|21.5%|9.1%|10.1%|3.1% / 2.8%|
|MNST|20.2%|12.5%|20.2%|20.1% / 20.8%|
|AAPL|16.9%|5.5%|15.1%|28.4% / 27.8%|
|KO|13.7%|7.8%|7.1%|28.0% / 21.3%|
|NVDA|13.9%|66.9%|83.4%|41.9% / 44.4%|

Required FCF growth and revenue growth are not the same number. They only line up if the FCF margin stays flat. So for the first five names the gap can close in two ways: revenue grows a lot faster than it has, or more of each dollar of revenue turns into free cash flow. I worked through the second path. Revenue keeps growing at its five-year pace for ten more years, and the question is what FCF margin year ten would need:

* Walmart: about 12% (11% on the capex-normalized number), vs. 1.8% today
* Costco: 9.1%, vs. 3.1% today
* Monster: 38.8%, vs. 20.1% today
* Apple: 78.9%, vs. 28.4% today
* Coca-Cola: 48.0%, vs. 28.0% today

What I take from it:

1. Walmart is the extreme case. Even with capex at its usual share of revenue, year ten needs a margin more than five times its five-year median. The bull case I usually hear for Walmart (ads, marketplace, membership) is a margin story, so maybe that is exactly what's being priced. It's still a big bet.
2. Apple and Monster are priced for last year, not for the last five. Against TTM revenue growth, Monster needs no margin expansion at all and Apple goes from 28% to about 33%. So the price assumes the last twelve months weren't a one-off.
3. Coke looks modest at 13.7%, but that's still almost twice its revenue growth, and its current FCF margin already sits well above its five-year median.
4. Nvidia is the mirror image. The price asks for 13.9% a year, about a fifth of its five-year revenue pace. The market clearly isn't extrapolating the boom.

Further hints:

* Zero growth after year 10 is harsh and pushes every number up. With a 15-year horizon: WMT 19.2%, COST 15.7%, MNST 14.8%, AAPL 12.5%, KO 10.3%, NVDA 10.4%. The order stays the same.
* At an 8% or 10% discount rate, Walmart lands at 24.5% or 28.9%. Same picture.
* FCF here is before stock-based comp. Taking SBC out would push Apple's and Nvidia's numbers up.
* Five-year windows depend on the start year. Coke's starts in 2020, a weak pandemic year. From 2021 it's 5.5% a year, which makes the gap bigger, not smaller.
* It's arithmetic on today's price, not a forecast. Not investment advice.

For the defensive names, which path do you think the market is pricing: faster revenue, or a structurally higher margin? Do you see the needed growth rates as realistic?

I ran this with a screener I built for myself. Happy to run other tickers the same way in the comments.

document fetched 2026-11-17 00:44 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/ValueInvesting/comments/1xy0aoo/the_safe_names_are_priced_for_16_to_54_times