How much should a shop's machine mix tell me about their quote? (5-axis vs 4-axis vs 3+2)
retained text
800 pieces, four machined faces, and the same sentence from every supplier in different words: "we have 30 CNC machines." One of them broke it down as 5 five-axis, 10 four-axis and 15 three-plus-two. I genuinely don't know whether that is a good sign, a bad sign, or just a number they all recite. My part: 140 x 80 x 30 mm extruded body, 1.6 mm wall, 6063, clear anodized. Machining is a front panel opening, two M4 threaded holes per end, a DIN rail slot on the back, and a pocket for a PCB standoff pattern. Features land on four faces. First run 800 pcs, then maybe 4,000 a year. So my questions for people who actually quote this stuff: 1. Does a mixed fleet mean anything, or is it just what a shop accumulates over ten years? I assume a shop with 15 three-plus-two machines is optimised for simple parts in volume, and that if my part has features on four faces, it will run across three setups on those machines instead of one on a five-axis. Is that true, or does a good fixture make the difference irrelevant at this quantity? 2. Where is the crossover? I've been told that below a few hundred pieces the setup cost dominates and you want fewer setups even at a higher hourly rate. Above that, the cheaper per-hour machine wins as long as the tolerance holds. Is there a rough quantity where you'd move a part off the five-axis and onto three-plus-two, or does it depend entirely on the geometry? 3. What actually drives the price of a four-face part? If my part runs on a 4-axis with an indexer, is the fourth face basically free compared to the fifth? Or is the real cost the fixture design, which nobody quotes separately? 4. Is "we do everything in-house" a real signal here? One quote is noticeably higher and the shop says the extrusion, machining and anodizing are all under one roof, so nobody can point at anybody else. Another is 20% cheaper and subcontracts the anodizing. I've read enough threads here to know that the cheapest quote often becomes the most expensive one, but I'd like to understand the mechanism rather than just take it on faith. 5. The thing I'm most worried about Tolerance stack. If my part gets machined in three setups, the datums get re-established three times. Do shops normally verify the cumulative error against the drawing, or do you only find out when the assembly doesn't close? I'm not looking for a supplier recommendation and I'm not linking anything. I'm trying to read a quote properly before I commit to an 800-piece run. Happy to be told my framing is wrong.
document fetched 2026-10-31 00:41 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/manufacturing/comments/1xj3mh8/how_much_should_a_shops_machine_mix_tell_me_about