Does Benner's 150-year market cycle theory actually work?
retained text
I came across this chart called “Periods When to Make Money,” attributed to Samuel Benner. It identifies specific years for financial panics, good times/high prices (when to sell), and hard times/low prices (when to buy). Some of its dates seem interesting when compared with historical events: \- 1999 and the dot-com bubble \- 2007 and the global financial crisis \- 2019 and the COVID-era market crash that followed \- 2026, which the chart identifies as a high-price year \- 2035, which it identifies as a potential panic year However, when I compared some of these dates with annual S&P 500 returns, several predictions didn't match the market's direction. My questions: 1. Has anyone backtested Benner's cycle theory against historical stock market data? 2. How accurate were its predictions for market tops, bottoms and financial panics? 3. Does the original theory concern commodities rather than stocks, and are modern versions of the chart interpreting it correctly? 4. Is there any statistical evidence that these cycles have predictive value, or are the apparent matches simply hindsight bias? I'm interested in a data-driven analysis, including failed predictions—not just examples that appear to confirm the theory. What do you think? Is there anything substantive behind Benner's cycles?
document fetched 2026-10-15 00:49 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/IndianStockMarket/comments/1x5dmfy/does_benners_150year_market_cycle_theory_actually