← sources

What is everyone doing for a key provider for vTPM to deploy Server 2025?

source: reddit (reddit:sysadmin)published 2026-10-23 12:30ingested 2026-10-24 02:39

retained text

My team has been telling my org for 3+ years that we need a third party Key Provider appliance to use to handle the vTPM keys to deploy Server 2025 in a robust/scalable/safe way. 

We *could* use the built in key providers from vmware stuff, but when trialing it, didn't get a good feeling about recoverability, srm, etc.  

We also have a Nutanix environment (with AHV) and did deploy one 2025 server with a vTPM there a couple years ago, but Nutanix doesn't (or didn't? not sure if it changed) have a way to connect an external key provider, and at the time we found that the VM w/ the vTPM couldn't be moved across clusters in the event of a cluster level HA need.

I know vTPM implementations and support have improved since then, but my team has been holding hard to the request for an external key provider and refusing to deploy 2025 servers to production workloads.  They finally approved it for the FY26 budget, but when it came to it, wouldn't OK the purchase.

Are we sticking to a requirement that's unnecessary with current vTPM key provider implementations on vmware?  How is everyone else handling it?

document fetched 2026-10-24 10:38 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/sysadmin/comments/1xdcotf/what_is_everyone_doing_for_a_key_provider_for