← sources

HOOD Seems super overvalued

source: reddit (reddit:ValueInvesting)published 2026-10-20 02:22ingested 2026-10-21 02:41

retained text

Hi All, I did a deep dive into HOOD stock. I saw the news today that SEC will allow off hours options trading and thought this is amazing news for HOOD.

**How do they make money** (Revenues are listed for 2025 and CAGR was caclualted for last 3 years)   
Total Revenue was 4.4 B (CAGR 56%)

A. Transaction-Based Revenues (Payment for Order Flow) : Robinhood routes retail buy and sell requests to high-frequency trading firms (like Citadel Securities or Virtu). These firms pay Robinhood a fraction of a cent per share or dollar traded to execute the order - > 2.6 Billion (CAGR 82%)

=>Options \~ 1.1 B (CAGR 50%)  
=> **The other type of currency I cant list here because I get banned ffs**\~ 0.9 B (CAGR 158%)  
=> Equities \~ 0.3 B (CAGR 70%)

B. Net interest revenues : They make money by sweeping univested customer cash partner banks or safe short-term bonds, pocketing the "spread" between what the market pays and what they give back to users.  
And also by Margin lending. = > 1.5 B (CAGR 27%)

C. Other revenues : Robinhood Gold , etc. => 0.6 B (CAGR 73%)

**Operating Margin :** It was negative in 2023 during the growth phase, 24% in 2024 and 42 % in 2025   
=> Its a very healthy and scalable business, there was a small increase in operating expense from 2024 to 2025 due to marketing and G&A, but the actual core business expense are very low considering the revenue expansion.

Here is a link to my DCF Model -> [https://www.mediafire.com/file/9c84obdv1iq3vy1/HOOD-v2.xls/file](https://www.mediafire.com/file/9c84obdv1iq3vy1/HOOD-v2.xls/file)

Key assumptions : Discount rate of 14%, because it has high Beta), terminal growth rate of 3% and first 10 year growth rate of 20% (This is based on FCF CAGR) and I got a fair value of \~ 42 $ for this stock with my unbiased assumptions.

Next I did a sort of Reverse DCF -> If I fix the discount rate to 14%, then I need around 30 % 10 year growth to justify 96 $ stock price.

Or more likely if I reduce the Discount rate to 10 %, then I need around 22 % growth over next 10 years.

**Investing in HOOD , Pros and cons for growth:**

Pros:

1. Investing is becoming increasingly speculative and gambling has also become a big problem recently, with the explosive growth of options/other type of currency, HOOD is best positions to capture this market
2. Pure Speculation : In the medium term, HOOD is the only brokerage which is using agentic AI and I beleive once open AI agents become good enough this will reduce the dominance of investing firms and democratize some edge back to non retail investors.

Cons:

1. I can definetely see a world where a lot of restrictions/lawsuits are made against HOOD because of their promotion of almost gamling like behavior and also shady practices like payment of order flow.
2. A lot of investors are speculating that next financial crisis maybe due to 0 DTE trading and HOOD will likely be at the center of this.

**Final Verdict:**

A lot of actual growth has already been priced in, and either the company would have to prove some additional growth drivers to justify its current stock price or I would have to think that the market is still overly underestimating the explosive growth in users.

If I look at the pricing, the market seems to be willing to price it at extreme multiples like around 50-60 PE when there is a boom in other options trading/other type of currency (Like eary 2025/2026). Also I see my friends are really getting into options trading and I don't see any slowdown for this market.

However at current price of 96 $, I am not convinced this is a good long term buy.... It's way to speculative, but I will keep a close eye to see if there is any new proven growth driver or if there is a bigger pullback

document fetched 2026-10-21 00:44 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/ValueInvesting/comments/1xag7rd/hood_seems_super_overvalued