← sources

Rationally trying to understand why Gyanesh Kumar can't be removed by GoI?

source: reddit (reddit:india)published 2026-10-11 09:25ingested 2026-10-12 02:37

retained text

Why can't Gyanesh Kumar be removed is a question am trying to understand

Dharmendra Pradhan was removed - still Government controlled all shots with maybe a blot on their credibility & more so ever on HM's position within government & their party.

All possibilities i can think of :

1. Gyanu has some insider information which when made public will remove BJP from power for more than a decade.
2. HM is fighting a lonely battle with all mercenaries (delhi police majorly) at his behest. Reason being such barbaric police behaviour is not seen in Mumbai, Bengaluru.
3. Removing Gyanu will lead to CJI & HM & PM resignation but it is far fetched.

At this stage - BJP should not be worrying about UP elections, 2029 Lok Sabha rather about their long term credibility to be able to win back voters, public sentiments.

The rate at which the current conflict is playing out in mass + global media (Now mainstream channels are also showing the protest LIVE so all Mummy Papas are watching) is hampering BJP's image more.

CJP & Opposition are playing optics with HM giving them the baton.

Had I been in their position - I would quietly have removed Gyanesh Kumar when the Indian Express news came out & replaced with a more neutral person which would have cost me UP elections maybe but I would have a shot at 2029 Lok Sabha elections.  
But most importantly I would have saved PM, BJP's credibility & given HM a shot at becoming PM in future.

BJP is shooting itself in the foot & is going to pay a heavy price because this youth will decide the narrative & they won't stop at anything.

***to all the bjp supporters here disliking facts - try to be rationale on facts sometimes!***

***Disliking, disagreeing, being negative won't change the truth & its TOO BIG this time to negate by any PR or Jumla - you know it :)***

document fetched 2026-10-12 00:25 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/india/comments/1x33s0i/rationally_trying_to_understand_why_gyanesh_kumar