← sources

Vested's Incorrect Schedule FA Report: ITR-U Already Filed. Any BMA Penalty or FAST-DS Risk? Please help... πŸ™

source: reddit (reddit:IndiaTax)published 2026-09-30 14:28ingested 2026-10-01 02:46

retained text

First of all, a huge thank you to Nikhil Sir, u/Responsible-Bad-6624, for his incredibly detailed and helpful post on FAST DS 2026: https://www.reddit.com/r/IndiaTax/comments/1wrew9f/fastds\_2026\_note\_and\_qa/. It was very informative and helped me understand several aspects of the scheme.

I urgently need help regarding **Schedule FA, the Black Money Act (BMA), and FAST DS 2026**, as I am quite anxious about my situation.

In March 2026, my CA filed ITR U for three previous years using Vested's automated Schedule FA report, which I recently discovered contains significant errors. I've attached screenshots comparing it with my actual US broker transaction ledger.

# 1. Background

I started investing in US stocks through Vested in 2022. All my investments were made using legitimate funds from my salary, personal borrowings and family gifts, with remittances made through bank under LRS.

I filed my Indian income tax returns on time for FY 2022–23, FY 2023–24 and FY 2024–25. But, **I missed reporting my foreign dividends, capital gains and foreign assets in Schedule FA.** I was not even aware that these also needs to be shown.

In March 2026, my CA filed ITR U for all three years. We also paid the applicable capital gains taxes, interest and additional tax under Section 140B on the skipped foreign income.

# 2. The problem with Vested's Schedule FA report

My CA relied on Vested's Schedule FA report while filing the ITR Us. However, when I compared it with my actual Vested transaction statement, I found that few financial figures were incorrect.

The stock names and purchase dates appear to be correct. The initial investment value, peak value, closing value, gross sales proceeds, and company addresses and ZIP codes are incorrect in some entries.



**I've attached screenshots highlighting the discrepancies between Vested's report and my actual transaction records.**

# i). CY 2022

[CY 2022 Schedule FA, Vested Generated](https://preview.redd.it/1dmach8x1hsh1.png?width=1774&format=png&auto=webp&s=ba3cf010375427d5f7fc530bd39d3b8ad8a58a12)

[Transaction Ledger, Vested](https://preview.redd.it/2gcds0tl2hsh1.png?width=1579&format=png&auto=webp&s=a11c852bef08de765c71ed510b4aed2a05ef94c6)

Here, you can see the initial cost invested. I bought exactly **$181.00** of each of the 7 stocks on the same day (13-06-2022). All initial values should be identical (\~**β‚Ή14,143.88**), but Vested generated random figures ranging from **β‚Ή8,249.56** to **β‚Ή14,143.88**.

  
Similarly for CY 23, 24.

# ii). CY 2025

[CY 2025 Schedule FA, Vested Generated](https://preview.redd.it/d59pj8u78hsh1.png?width=1800&format=png&auto=webp&s=8daa4113e6de3ce21927f9778aa424df75f7aa10)

For stocks like Apple, Microsoft, Alphabet and NVIDIA, Vested reported the **peak value as equal to the initial value (β‚Ή14,143.88)**. Some stocks also have incorrect ZIP codes, and closing values are missing altogether, among other discrepancies.



**Unfortunately, as I understand it, only one ITR U can be filed for an assessment year. Since the returns have already been updated, I cannot simply file another ITR U to correct these figures.**

https://preview.redd.it/gpq7au9g1osh1.png?width=2123&format=png&auto=webp&s=7f9d4f1824cf5b14cafb9119b4ab2283b9f8c9e7

https://preview.redd.it/5yjd94qq1osh1.png?width=2122&format=png&auto=webp&s=55a61f6dc1e18977397d3903c731cf34ebd4d617

https://preview.redd.it/qg58a9902osh1.png?width=2170&format=png&auto=webp&s=10c636f01fa821f88de9336704187aa636881a4d

# 3. My foreign portfolio value

After reviewing my vested records, I found that the peak value (Cash+Stocks) of my portfolio was below β‚Ή20 lakh during each of FY 2022–23, FY 2023–24 and FY 2024–25.

However, my portfolio crossed β‚Ή20 lakh during FY 2025–26.

# 4. My questions

**1. Can I still face the β‚Ή10 lakh penalty under Section 43?**

Since my actual foreign asset value was below β‚Ή20 lakh in FY 2022–23, FY 2023–24 and FY 2024–25, does the β‚Ή20 lakh threshold protect me from the penalty?

More importantly, does this protection also apply when the foreign assets have been disclosed through ITR U, but the reported particulars, such as initial value, peak value and closing value, are incorrect?

**2. Do I need to opt for FAST DS 2026?**

Would I need to pay β‚Ή1 lakh under FAST DS 2026, or would the scheme be unnecessary in my case?

The assets were already disclosed through ITR U in March 2026, before receiving any notice, and their actual values were below β‚Ή20 lakh for all three previous financial years.

>But, Nikhil Sir, u/Responsible-Bad-6624, has mentioned that *"First, do not use ITR-U for undisclosed foreign income: section 4 of the Black Money Act does not recognise an updated return as a way of regularising untaxed foreign income, so the income-tax gets paid and the BMA exposure stays open."*

Given this, does filing ITR U and paying the applicable taxes make any difference to my FAST DS 2026 eligibility or BMA liability? Also, is an incorrect disclosure treated differently from a complete failure to disclose foreign assets?

**3. What should I do about the previous ITR U filings?**

Would it be sufficient to maintain a detailed reconciliation prepared by my CA, supported by the original broker statements, transaction ledger, remittance records and relevant calculations, in case the department raises a query?

I would prefer to address the issue proactively rather than risk complications later.

**4. What about FY 2025–26, when my portfolio crossed β‚Ή20 lakh?**

For AY 2026–27, the applicable filing deadline is currently 31 December 2026.

**Do I use Vested’s transaction ledger to file my Schedule FA by manually calculating everything?**

If I file an accurate ITR 2 before the applicable deadline, with the correct Schedule FA figures and all relevant foreign dividends and capital gains properly reported, would that take care of my compliance obligations for this year?

# 5. My main concern

All my investments were made using legitimate, documented funds, and I have the relevant bank and broker records. The problem is that I relied on Vested's automated report, which I now know contains substantial errors.

I am primarily concerned about whether inaccurate particulars in an ITR U that has already been filed are treated differently from a complete failure to disclose foreign assets, particularly in relation to the β‚Ή20 lakh threshold and the FAST DS 2026 scheme.

I would really appreciate advice from anyone familiar with these provisions.

Thank you...

document fetched 2026-10-01 00:50 Β· canonical https://reddit.com/r/IndiaTax/comments/1wu6fhk/vesteds_incorrect_schedule_fa_report_itru_already