← sources

AI causing an argument among the team - who is correct?

source: reddit (reddit:sysadmin)published 2026-09-23 12:26ingested 2026-09-24 02:39

retained text

A user claims they used to be able to search a file share from their local machine, but with their brand new computer we issued them, they can no longer do this.

This user is known to stretch the truth to get what they want, but our team all agrees that they “probably“ were able to search their network share back in the day.

This is where AI comes in. AI told us of course you can search a file share. just make sure the share is set as Always Offline, and then include it in the local index. OR, we can turn on the Windows Search Service on the file server to index the whole system.

Some of us on the team think we should restart the Windows Search Service and reindex the entire share, and some of us say we should just locally index this user’s personal share within the server.

This seems like a trivial discussion, but now everybody is stuck opining based off AI’s response...  has this ever happened to your team? What would you do to sway opinion on a course of action here? I can’t argue for or against an AI tool’s response. The tool will always have a more compelling argument than my own.

document fetched 2026-09-24 00:40 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/sysadmin/comments/1wo4kyw/ai_causing_an_argument_among_the_team_who_is