← sources

Used Dell R730xd vs new i5-14400 tower for a home server

source: reddit (reddit:homelab)published 2026-11-16 17:44ingested 2026-11-17 02:40

retained text

Hey everyone,

I’m looking at replacing my current home server and could use a reality check. I keep going back and forth between a refurbished Dell R730xd and building a new Intel tower.

Honestly, this is probably **80% hobby/toy and 20% actual need**. I like learning and messing around with hardware, but I also don’t want to buy something I’ll regret running 24/7.

# My current setup

* Dell Precision T3500
* Xeon W3550 — 4 cores / 8 threads
* Around 20 GB DDR3 RAM
* Proxmox, mostly running LXC containers
* **2× SATA 2.5" SSDs in a ZFS mirror** for the system
* **2× Toshiba 22 TB SATA 3.5" HDDs in a ZFS mirror** for data

Current services:

* Jellyfin
* Immich
* Forgejo
* qBittorrent
* A few smaller things

The current machine mostly does what I need. The painful parts are media processing, thumbnail/trickplay generation, and transcoding.

Most of my media is **1080p**, including **HEVC Main10 HDR**. I’d like enough headroom for roughly **3–5 concurrent streams**, potentially including HDR-to-SDR transcoding, although that isn’t a constant workload.

I’d also like to add:

* A self-hosted calendar
* Email backups/archive
* OPNsense and better control over my home network: firewall rules, traffic visibility, DNS filtering, possibly VLANs

My connection is Vodafone cable/DOCSIS, around **1 Gbps down and 100–250 Mbps up**. Their modem supports bridge mode.

# Option 1: Refurbished Dell PowerEdge R730xd

The configuration I’ve been considering:

* **12×3.5" front bays**
* **2× Xeon E5-2690 v4 — 28 cores / 56 threads total**
* **32 GB DDR4 ECC RAM, initially 2×16 GB**
* **HBA330** for ZFS
* **2×750 W redundant PSUs**
* iDRAC8 Enterprise
* Complete rack rails
* Four drive trays, including adapters for the two SSDs
* 12-month seller warranty

The quote was approximately **€686 including VAT**, with an Intel X520/I350 network daughter card providing **2×10Gb SFP+ and 2×1Gb RJ45**. I’m considering switching that to **4×1Gb Intel I350**, since everything I currently use is gigabit.

I would reuse all four existing drives. No GPU initially, but a used **Quadro P2000** is a possible later addition for Jellyfin.

With a basic adjustable open rack, the total would be roughly **€780–800**, or around **€850 with a used P2000**, depending on the final prices.

What attracts me:

* Proper drive bays and straightforward expansion
* I’d like room for **6–10 total drives eventually**
* ECC, iDRAC, redundant PSUs, serviceability
* Plenty of room to experiment
* And, honestly, **rack servers look badass**

My concerns:

* **Idle power consumption**
* **Noise**
* Physical size/depth
* Buying a lot of hardware I may never really use

The server would be **in my bedroom**, so noise matters. A steady hum is tolerable; a high-pitched fan whine would be much worse. I’ve heard some 2U servers running in an office and didn’t find them unbearable, but I know that doesn’t tell me how this particular R730xd will behave.

I found [this ServeTheHome review](https://www.servethehome.com/lenovo-system-x3650-m5-workhorse-2u-server-review/) of a Lenovo x3650 M5 with the **same dual E5-2690 v4 CPUs**, 128 GB RAM and two SAS SSDs. They measured **79 W idle**. Obviously that isn’t the same chassis or configuration, but it made me question some of the much higher estimates people give for dual-Xeon systems.

I haven’t measured my current T3500’s consumption yet, either.

# Option 2: New Intel tower

A rough build from a local Czech retailer:

* **Intel Core i5-14400, non-F**, so I get UHD 730 / Quick Sync
* **ASUS PRIME B760-PLUS D4**
* **32 GB DDR4-3200 CL16, 2×16 GB G.Skill Aegis**
* **Cooler Master Force 500**, which has multiple 3.5" bays
* Suitable PSU, additional cooling and drive adapters
* Reuse the same SSD and HDD mirrors

Estimated total: approximately **16,000–18,000 CZK / €660–740**, depending on the PSU and accessories. So broadly the same price range as the Dell itself, and cheaper than the Dell plus rack and GPU.

The board has four SATA ports, so it covers my current drives. I would need an additional SATA controller/HBA for expansion, and an extra NIC if I virtualize OPNsense and want multiple physical network ports.

What attracts me:

* Quick Sync available immediately
* Likely lower idle consumption
* Easier to make quiet
* Smaller and easier to fit in the room
* Faster individual CPU cores
* New components

What I’d miss:

* iDRAC and the enterprise-server experience
* ECC with this particular build
* Hot-swap drive bays
* The convenience of a chassis already designed for lots of disks
* The rack-server cool factor 😅

For context, the PassMark results I found put the **dual Xeons at around 30.5k multi-thread**, versus **25k for the i5-14400**, while the i5 is much faster in single-thread performance. I realize those numbers don’t directly predict Jellyfin, Immich or real-world VM performance.

# I also considered mini PCs

I like the idea of a small custom rack with one mini PC initially, then adding another and splitting services later — for example, a dedicated Jellyfin node.

However, I keep getting stuck on storage. I want to retain my large SATA HDDs and expand later, and I’m not looking to buy a conventional Synology/QNAP NAS.

A custom hot-swap disk enclosure sounds cool, but once I start figuring out USB DAS vs external SATA/SAS, power supplies, cooling and sharing storage between nodes, it feels like it could become more complicated and expensive than either of the other options.

# What would you do?

I think my real dilemma is:

>**The tower seems like the sensible choice, but the Dell is the one that makes me excited about the hardware. Meanwhile, my current server mostly works, so I’m not even sure how much of this upgrade I actually need.**

I’d particularly appreciate:

* **Real idle-power and noise experiences with a lightly populated R730xd**, ideally with E5 v4 CPUs
* Whether an **i5-14400 with Quick Sync** makes more sense for this workload
* Any major limitations I’m overlooking in the tower build
* Whether you bought an old enterprise rack server for fun and loved it — or eventually replaced it with something quieter and more efficient

Nothing has been ordered yet. Feel free to talk me into or out of either option. 😄

*(translated by AI bcs my english is not good enough)*

document fetched 2026-11-17 00:37 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/homelab/comments/1xxvvqv/used_dell_r730xd_vs_new_i514400_tower_for_a_home