← sources

Retired parent’s ₹40 lakh tax case; officials informally asked us to withdraw waiver application. NEED ADVICE

source: reddit (reddit:IndiaTax)published 2026-10-11 07:44ingested 2026-10-12 02:40

retained text

My retired father receives a very small pension and has huge medical burden from active treatment for his Wife's cancer and Mother's knee transplant surgeries. **The case involves approximately ₹40 lakh overall, comprising the assessment demand already paid and separate penalty demands still outstanding.**

An earlier tax consultant advised a political donation and filed returns containing unsupported claims, then stopped responding.

**What happened over the past several months:**

\- The department disallowed claims under **80GGC, 10(13A), 10(5), 80E, 80D and 80CCD(1B)**. Following assessment under **143(3) read with 144B**, we accepted the additions, did not appeal the assessment, and paid the entire assessment demand, including interest and recovery of an earlier refund, within time.

\- We sought immunity through **Form 68 under 270AA**. Further **100% additional income-tax on under-reported income** was required before immunity could be considered. We could not afford that payment without certainty of relief, and immunity was rejected.

\- Separate penalties were imposed under **270A** at the 200% misreporting rate, **271DA relating to 269ST** for alleged donation-related cash receipt, and **272A(1)(d)** for alleged notice non-compliance. We deny receiving donation money back in cash.

\- We submitted a **273A(4) hardship/penalty-waiver application to PCIT.** In informal discussions, departmental officials asked us to withdraw it and indicated that other assessment years could also be examined. **This was unofficial, not a written direction.**

\- We already filed **ITR-U for affected subsequent years to remove donation deductions**. The fund administrator has now confirmed that post-retirement PF interest is taxable, but we treated it as exempt under 10(2) in some returns. Those errors remain, and another ITR-U cannot ordinarily be filed for the same AY.

Our biggest concern is **1% monthly interest under 220(2)** on unpaid demands and potentially exhausting his retirement savings.

Finding reliable help has also been difficult. One professional charged huge sum to draft Vakalatnaama for notice responses but later refused appeal work. Another took money claiming he could influence officials through unofficial payments, then disappeared. 

**Specific asks:**

1. Should we proceed with the 273A(4) withdrawal suggestion as per PCIT officers? Or should we continue **273A(4)** while filing **Form 35 penalty appeals** and seeking a recovery stay?

2. Can we seek **220(3) instalments** without withdrawing the application or surrendering appeal rights? How should we approach **220(2A) interest relief**?

3. How can we lawfully disclose PF income missed in an **already-filed ITR-U** and pay the additional liability?

4. How do we find and vet a trustworthy tax-litigation advocate/CA who handles penalty appeals and hearings? What credentials, written scope and fee terms should we insist on?

5. Is there any other way to tackle this besides filing Appeal. Also, if we lose Appeal, I understand we gotta pay 1% simple interest for all those months that the case ran until disposal?

document fetched 2026-10-12 00:40 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/IndiaTax/comments/1x325g0/retired_parents_40_lakh_tax_case_officials