← sources

Nano Banana 2.1 just dropped, so I put it in a blind test against 3 other image models

source: reddit (reddit:ChatGPT)published 2026-10-23 17:56ingested 2026-10-24 02:35

retained text

wanted to try Nano Banana 2.1 on something a little more annoying than a pretty portrait, so I gave it and three other image models the exact same workshop prompt.

I ran all four through atlas cloud so I could switch models without rewriting the prompt. First generation only, no model-specific tweaks. I used the closest native 4:3 option each endpoint offered and otherwise left the settings pretty much at default.

the prompt included a few things I could check directly: a red vise on the left, a blue cabinet on the right, a cardboard sign reading PARTS RETURN, exactly three wrenches on the pegboard, wet footprints, and a clock showing 8:17.

what surprised me was the sign. I expected text to be the first thing to fall apart, but all four got PARTS RETURN basically right. The clock, though? None of them got 8:17 right.

A and B were the only two that gave me exactly three wrenches. C gave me two. D gave me four, despite the prompt explicitly saying not to add extras lol.

visually, they went in pretty different directions too. A followed the constraints really well, though it looks a little more processed. B feels the most like a normal photo to me. C got the “someone actually works here” clutter right, even if it lost a wrench along the way. D looks convincing too, but the room feels a little more arranged than I asked for.

for anyone comparing costs, here's what each request cost:

* A: $0.0175
* B: $0.00438
* C: $0.072
* D: $0.06

that ended up being almost as interesting as the images. The listed starting price wasn't always what the request actually cost.

reveal:

* A: Nano Banana 2.1 Developer
* B: GPT Image 2.5 Sunburst
* C: Seedream v5.0 Pro
* D: Grok Imagine Image 2.0

this is still just one result from each model, and the endpoints don't expose identical native resolutions or settings. I'd keep that in mind when comparing them.

which image would you pick before the reveal, and would seeing the prices change your answer?

document fetched 2026-10-24 10:23 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/ChatGPT/comments/1xdl51x/nano_banana_21_just_dropped_so_i_put_it_in_a